| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 PROGRESS Freedom's Road Tapings
Jun 27th 2017 | R. J. Singh | def. | Connor Mills, Mirko Mori, Spike Trivet | four-way | |
PROGRESS Chapter 53: Fate Loves The Fearless
Jul 30th 2017 | Connor Mills | def. | Spike Trivet | dark
| |
PROGRESS Chapter 54: Go To Your God Like a Soldier
Aug 27th 2017 | Strangler Davis | def. | Connor Mills | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 56: La Danse Macabre
Oct 29th 2017 | Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis & Omari | def. | Alex Cupid & Connor Mills & Dillon D'Angelo | 6-person tag | |
PROGRESS Live at The Dome #1
Nov 15th 2017 | Alex Cupid & Dillon D'Angelo | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 58: Live Your Best Life
Nov 26th 2017 | Jimmy Havoc & Mark Haskins | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS Live at the Dome #3
Jan 10th 2018 | Maverick Mayhew | def. | Connor Mills | | |
PROGRESS Live at the Dome #4
Feb 7th 2018 | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | def. | Alex Cupid & Dillon D'Angelo, Ashmore & Matt Walters, Gideon Grey & Kurtis Chapman | four-way tag | |
PROGRESS Live at the Dome #5
Mar 14th 2018 | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | def. | Gavin Lewis & Screwface | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 68: Super Strong 16 Tournament Edition 2018 - Day 3
May 7th 2018 | Flash Morgan Webster & Mark Haskins | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 69: Be Here Now
May 20th 2018 | Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 70: May 27th 1978
May 27th 2018 | Flash Morgan Webster & Mark Haskins | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS World Cup 2018
Jun 13th 2018 | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | def. | Davey Vega & Mat Fitchett | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 72: Got Got Need
Jun 24th 2018 | Chris Brookes & Kid Lykos | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS Live at the Dome #6
Jul 18th 2018 | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | def. | David Starr & Jack Sexsmith | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 75: These Violent Delights Have Violent Ends
Aug 27th 2018 | James Drake & Zack Gibson | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
 PROGRESS/wXw PROGRESS Germany Tour 2018: Oberhausen
Sep 1st 2018 | Chief Deputy Dunne & Los Federales Santos Jr. | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS/wXw PROGRESS Germany Tour 2018: Frankfurt
Sep 2nd 2018 | Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis | def. | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 76: Hello Wembley!
Sep 30th 2018 | Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis | def. | Bandido (c) & Flamita (c) & Chris Brookes & Timothy Thatcher & Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew & David Starr & Jack Sexsmith & James Drake & Zack Gibson & Flash Morgan Webster & Wild Boar & Chief Deputy Dunne & Los Federales Santos Jr. | Thunderbastard (tag) | PROGRESS Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
FCP Infinity 2018
Oct 26th 2018 | Chief Deputy Dunne | draw (NC) | Chuck Mambo, Connor Mills, Drew Parker, Scotty Davis, Valkyrie | "Scramble" | |
FCP WrestleHouse 2019
Feb 1st 2019 | Omari | def. | Connor Mills | | |
Wrestle Gate Enter The Dragons
Mar 16th 2019 | Connor Mills & Maverick Mayhew | def. | Harrison Bourne & Joe Lando | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 87: Breadknife
Mar 31st 2019 | David Starr | def. | Connor Mills | | |
 DWW/FCP Fight For Destiny
Apr 4th 2019 | Chuck Mambo | def. | Connor Mills | | |
FCP Dream Tag Team Invitational 2019 - Day 2
Apr 20th 2019 | Dan Moloney | def. | Chief Deputy Dunne, Chuck Mambo, Connor Mills, Eita, El Phantasmo, Frightmare, Jeff Cobb, Rey Horus, Sami Callihan | 10-Way | |
Connor Mills