| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WrestleCade WrestleCade 2015
Nov 28th 2015 | Ethan Carter III | def. | Alex Rain, Andrew Lockhart, Asaafi, Bill Dundee, Bill Mulkey, Bobby Fulton, Brutus Beefcake, Bunkhouse Buck, Colt Cabana, Erik Lockhart, Ernest Miller, Garett Bischoff, George South, Glacier, Greg Valentine, Jason Kincaid, Jimmy Valiant, Raj Singh, Randy Mulkey, Ryan Davidson, Sam Houston, Shane Douglas, The Blue Meanie, Unknown Male Wrestler | Battle Royal | |
Legends of Wrestling Youngstown Show
Nov 3rd 2013 | Brutus Beefcake | def. | The Bouncer | | |
Legends of Wrestling Marlins Park Show
Aug 24th 2013 | Brutus Beefcake | def. (pin) | Mike Knox | | |
Pro Wrestling Superstars WrestleReunion VI
Jan 28th 2012 | The Godfather | def. | Bradley Ray Schreck, Brutus Beefcake, Carlos Colon, Dan Severn, Gangrel, Greg Valentine, Jesse Hernandez, Jimmy Hart, Kevin Sullivan, Konnan, Lanny Poffo, Mando Guerrero, Matt Classic, Piloto Suicida, Raven, Robbie E., Rock Riddle, Tommy Dreamer, Virgil | enforcer: Ken Shamrock
Battle Royal | |
JCW Legends & Icons
Aug 12th 2011 | Zach Gowen | def. | Brutus Beefcake, Carlito, Disco Inferno, Doink the Clown (Borne), Headbanger Mosh, Headbanger Thrasher, Jim Duggan, Jimmy Snuka, Rikishi, Rob Conway, Ronnie Garvin, Tony Atlas, U-Gene, Viscera | Battle Royal | |
PWS Spring Break Showdown
Mar 5th 2011 | Brutus Beefcake | def. | Justin Corino | | |
GLCW Blizzard Brawl VI
Dec 4th 2010 | Ax (c) & Smash (c) | def. | Brutus Beefcake & Greg Valentine, Eric Freedom & Jimmy Blaze, Jared Johnsonville & Mase Morgan | four-way tag | GLCW Tag Team Titles
|
 Hulkamania Let The Battle Begin - Day 4
Nov 28th 2009 | Brutus Beefcake | def. (sub) | Orlando Jordan | | |
Hulkamania Let The Battle Begin - Day 3
Nov 26th 2009 | Brutus Beefcake & Mr. Anderson | def. (pin) | Orlando Jordan & Osu Fatu | | |
Hulkamania Let The Battle Begin - Day 2
Nov 24th 2009 | Osu Fatu | def. (pin) | Brutus Beefcake | | |
Hulkamania Let The Battle Begin - Day 1
Nov 21st 2009 | Brutus Beefcake | def. | Heidenreich | | |
DREAMWAVE Immortality 2009
Jun 6th 2009 | Brutus Beefcake | def. | Dan Lawrence | | |
PWS Refuse to Lose
May 17th 2008 | Greg Valentine | def. | Brutus Beefcake | | |
Wrestlefanfest Malice in the Palace
Oct 19th 2007 | Brutus Beefcake & Greg Valentine | def. (sub) | Koko B Ware & Steve Williams | | |
JCW Bloodymania
Aug 12th 2007 | Mad Man Pondo & Necro Butcher | def. | Human Tornado & Zach Gowen, Axl Rotten & Ian Rotten, Brutus Beefcake & Greg Valentine, Alofa & Samu, Akira Raijin & Brute Issei, Damaja & Doug Basham, Jorge Santana & Tito Santana | 8 Team Tag Team Elimination | JCW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
PMG Ultimate Clash of Legends
Apr 27th 2007 | Brutus Beefcake & Bubba the Love Sponge | def. | New Assassin #1 & New Assassin #2 | | |
i-G Superstars of Wrestling
Aug 3rd 2000 | Brute Force | def. | Typhoon | | |
i-G Rodman Down Under
Jul 30th 2000 | The Barbarian | def. | Brute Force | "hardcore" | |
WCW Saturday Night Taping (October '99 #1)
Oct 12th 1999 | Disco Inferno | def. | The Disciple | | |
WCW Saturday Night Taping (August '99 #2)
Aug 3rd 1999 | The Disciple | def. | The Barbarian | | |
WCW Saturday Night Taping (July '99 #1)
Jul 6th 1999 | The Disciple | def. | Bobby Blaze | | |
WCW Thunder Taping
Apr 29th 1999 | Randy Savage | def. (pin) | The Disciple | | |
WCW Thunder Taping
Apr 1st 1999 | Hulk Hogan | def. | The Disciple | | |
WCW Thunder Taping
Mar 18th 1999 | Disco Inferno | def. | The Disciple | | |
WCW Saturday Night Taping (March '99 #3)
Mar 16th 1999 | Kenny Kaos | def. | The Disciple | | |
Brutus Beefcake