The Internet Wrestling Database


Profile & Match ListingFacts & StatsPWI RatingsMerchandiseOpponents & PartnersWin/Loss RecordStar RatingsWin TypesRelationsPopularity

Below you can see all known star ratings for wrestling matches featuring in Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Please note that ratings are given to the overall match; not to the performers within them. Therefore, high or low ratings may reflect aspects of the match including booking, length and performance of partners/opponents, over which the performers may have little or no control. Please also note that a match that received a particular rating many years ago may have been judged on a different criteria from today's.

Following the same rating system devised in part by Jim Cornette, matches are rated from the lowest rating of -***** (-5) through to the highest rating of ***** (+5), with a small number of matches being rated above that theoretical maximum. Matches with a rating of zero stars are referred to as a "DUD" and an average match tends to score around a ** (2) rating. All ratings can only be considered subjective and this page is designed purely for reference purposes.


Promotion Search: AllWWE
Year Search: All200120022003200420052006200720082009
Matches Shown: 1 to 26 of 26 (firstprevnextlast) ... Results per page: 102550100250All ... Sort: newest firstoldest first ... Title Matches: Click to View
card/ datematchmatch typetitle(s)Rating
United States WWE Extreme Rules '09
Jun 7th 2009
C. M. Punkdef. UmagaSamoan strap*½ (1.5)
United States WWE Judgment Day '09
May 17th 2009
Umagadef. (pin)C. M. Punk***¼ (3.25)
United States WWE One Night Stand '08
Jun 1st 2008
Jeff Hardydef. (pin)Umagafalls count anywhere**¼ (2.25)
United States WWE WrestleMania XXIV
Mar 30th 2008
Batistadef. (pin)Umaga*¼ (1.25)
United States WWE No Way Out '08
Feb 17th 2008
Triple Hdef. (pin)Chris Jericho, Jeff Hardy, John Bradshaw Layfield, Shawn Michaels, Umaga"Elimination Chamber"**** (4.00)
United States WWE Royal Rumble '08
Jan 27th 2008
John Cenadef. Batista, Big Daddy V, C. M. Punk, Carlito, Chavo Guerrero, Chuck Palumbo, Cody Rhodes, Elijah Burke, Finlay, Hardcore Holly, Hornswoggle, Jamie Noble, Jimmy Snuka, John Morrison, Kane, Mark Henry, Mick Foley, Mr. Kennedy, Roddy Piper, Santino Marella, Shawn Michaels, Shelton Benjamin, Snitsky, The Great Khali, The Miz, The Undertaker, Tommy Dreamer, Triple H, Umaga30-man Royal Rumble****¼ (4.25)
United States WWE Monday Night Raw
Jan 7th 2008
Jeff Hardydef. (pin)Umagasteel cage**** (4.00)
United States WWE Survivor Series '07
Nov 18th 2007
Jeff Hardy & Kane & Rey Mysterio & Triple Hdef. (pin)Big Daddy V & Finlay & Montel Vontavious Porter & Mr. Kennedy & Umagahandicap "Survivor Series"***¼ (3.25)
United States WWE Cyber Sunday '07
Oct 28th 2007
Triple Hdef. (pin)Umagastreet fight***¾ (3.75)
United States WWE No Mercy '07
Oct 7th 2007
Triple H (c)def. (pin)UmagaWWE Championship
*½ (1.5)
United States WWE SummerSlam '07
Aug 26th 2007
Umaga (c)def. (pin)Carlito, Mr. Kennedytriple-threatWWE Intercontinental Championship
** (2.00)
United States WWE The Great American Bash '07
Jul 22nd 2007
Umaga (c)def. (pin)Jeff HardyWWE Intercontinental Championship
***½ (3.5)
United States WWE Vengeance: Night of Champions
Jun 24th 2007
Santino Marella (c)def. (DQ)UmagaWWE Intercontinental Championship
-* (-1)
United States WWE Judgment Day '07
May 20th 2007
Bobby Lashleydef. (pin)Mr. McMahon (c) & Shane McMahon & Umagahandicap tagECW World Heavyweight Title
DUD (0)
United States WWE Backlash '07
Apr 29th 2007
Mr. McMahon & Shane McMahon & Umagadef. (pin)Bobby Lashley (c)handicap tagECW World Heavyweight Title
(title change)
**¼ (2.25)
United States WWE WrestleMania 23
Apr 1st 2007
Bobby Lashleydef. (pin)Umagareferee: Steve Austin
hair vs. hair
*** (3.00)
United States WWE Royal Rumble '07
Jan 28th 2007
John Cena (c)def. (TKO)Umaga"Last Man Standing"WWE Championship
**** (4.00)
United States WWE New Year's Revolution '07
Jan 7th 2007
John Cena (c)def. (pin)UmagaWWE Championship
*** (3.00)
United States WWE Survivor Series '06
Nov 26th 2006
Bobby Lashley & John Cena & Kane & Rob Van Dam & Sabudef. (pin)Finlay & Montel Vontavious Porter & Test & The Big Show & Umaga"Survivor Series"**¼ (2.25)
United States WWE Cyber Sunday '06
Nov 5th 2006
Umagadef. (pin)Kane** (2.00)
Canada WWE Unforgiven '06
Sep 17th 2006
Kanedraw (DCO)Umaga*¼ (1.25)
United States WWE Vengeance '06
Jun 25th 2006
Umagadef. (pin)EugeneDUD (0)
United States WWE Backlash '06
Apr 30th 2006
Umagadef. (pin)Ric Flair*¼ (1.25)
United States WWE Royal Rumble '03
Jan 19th 2003
Brock Lesnardef. A-Train, B-2, Batista, Bill DeMott, Booker T., Charlie Haas, Chavo Guerrero, Chris Jericho, Chris Nowinski, Christian, Eddie Guerrero, Edge, Goldust, Jamal, Jeff Hardy, John Cena, Kane, Matt Hardy, Maven, Rey Mysterio, Rikishi, Rob Van Dam, Rosey, Shawn Michaels, Shelton Benjamin, Tajiri, Test, The Undertaker, Tommy Dreamer30-man Royal Rumble***¼ (3.25)
United States WWE Survivor Series '02
Nov 17th 2002
Bubba Ray Dudley & Jeff Hardy & Spike Dudleydef. Jamal & Rico & Roseyelimination tables (6-man tag)*** (3.00)
United States WWE Unforgiven '02
Sep 22nd 2002
Jamal & Roseydef. (pin)Billy & Chuck*¾ (1.75)

To show more matches, change the "Results per Page" value above.

When using information on this webpage elsewhere, please include a link to either of the following:


Popup and Spyware free; running on Apache/PHP/XHTML/MySQL

Delicious DeliciousDigg Diggreddit redditFacebook FacebookMySpace MySpaceStumbleUpon StumbleUponDelicious Twitter