| Date: Fri, Oct 14th 2005 | Pay Per View: no | 
| Venue:  | Promotion: IWA-MS | 
| Attendance: 40 | 
Matches for A Rotten Return| no. | match | duration | match type | title(s) | rating | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Trik Davis | def. | Darin Corbin | ||||
| 2 | C. J. Otis | def. | Jeff King, Jimmy Shalwin | three-way | |||
| 3 | Mickie Knuckles (c) | def. | Ann Thraxx | IWA:MS Womens Title | |||
| 4 | El Drunko (c) | def. | Larry Sweeney | NWA Indiana Heavyweight Title | |||
| 5 | Eddie Kingston | def. | Arik Cannon | ||||
| 6 | Orlando Colon | def. | Jack Thriller | ||||
| 7 | Josh Abercrombie (c) | draw (NC) | Brandon Thomaselli | IWA:MS Lightheavyweight Title | |||
| 8 | Chandler McClure & Eric Priest | def. | Marek Brave & Tyler Black | ||||
| 9 | Ian Rotten & Justin Credible | def. | Sal Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | ||||