| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 GCW Wasted Time
Dec 3rd 2022 | Ciclope (c) & Miedo Extremo (c) | def. | 2 Cold Scorpio & The Sandman, Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | three-way tag | GCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Gathering of the Juggalos 2019 - Day 2
Aug 2nd 2019 | Hy-Zaya & Mad Man Pondo & The Weedman | def. | Sabu & Shane Douglas & The Sandman | 6-person tag | |
Impact Wrestling Impact/Xplosion Tapings
Jun 6th 2019 | Killer Kross | draw (NC) | The Sandman | | |
MLW Superfight
Feb 2nd 2019 | Davey Boy Smith Jr. & Teddy Hart | def. | The Sandman & Tommy Dreamer | | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2018 - Supershow
Nov 24th 2018 | Fallah Bahh | def. | Axton Ray, Billy Brash, Bobby Fulton, Cam Carter, Chad Skywalker, Chris Hamrick, Dave Dawson, Dylan Fulton, Fred Rosser, Gary Wolfe, George South, Gigolo Justin, Glacier, Hurricane Helms, JB Cole, Jeremiah Plunkett, Keith Mac, LaBron Kozone, Mallaki Matthews, Mark Denny, Mike Camden, Mr. Hughes, Q. T. Marshall, Rex Bacchus, Ricky Roberts, Rob McBride, S.P. the Ghost, Sean Denny, Shane Douglas, Simon Gotch, Stan Lee, The Blue Meanie, The Sandman, Yahya, Zane Dawson, Zane Riley, Zuka King | Battle Royal | |
ROH Glory By Honor XVI - Night 2 TV Tapings
Oct 14th 2018 | Bully Ray & Silas Young | def. (pin) | Flip Gordon & The Sandman | Loser Gets Caned (tag) | |
Blitzkrieg! Pro Now You Know What We Are
May 12th 2018 | Shane Alden & The Sandman | def. | Malice & Orange Cassidy | | |
WCPBTW AdenaMania 3
Mar 3rd 2018 | The Sandman & Tyler Robinson | def. | Eric Fallen & Sabu | hardcore (tag) | |
PCW ULTRA Refuse to Lose
Dec 1st 2017 | Josef | def. | The Sandman | | |
PCW Demonized
Oct 6th 2017 | Brody King (c) & Josef (c) | draw (NC) | Masada & The Sandman | | PCW Tag Team Titles
|
Black Label Pro The Darkest Timeline Tournament Phase 1
Sep 23rd 2017 | The Sandman | def. | Everett Connors | | |
Blitzkrieg! Pro Disorder & Disarray
Jun 2nd 2017 | Isaiah Rex & The Sandman | def. | Dan De Man & Narciso Rex | | |
WCPBTW Memorial Weekend Mayhem
May 27th 2017 | The Sandman | def. | Tyler Robinson | "hardcore" | |
WrestleCon Supershow 2017
Mar 31st 2017 | The Sandman | def. | Joey Ryan (c) | | DDT Iron Man Heavy Metal Title
(title change) |
House of Hardcore #23
Dec 17th 2016 | The Sandman & Tommy Dreamer | def. | Kenny & Mikey | | |
JCW (NJ) Skate and Surf Festival - Day 2
May 17th 2015 | Chris Dickinson | def. | The Sandman | | |
FWE Welcome to the Rumble 2
Jun 21st 2013 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Alex Reynolds, Bandido Jr., Chris Masters, Chris Rockwell, Damien Darling, E. J. Risk, Exerguy JP, Exerguy M3, Jason Gotti, Jay Lethal, Jigsaw, Jimmy Wang Yang, Joey Ace, Johnny Knockout, Jorge Santi, Matt Jackson, Matt Striker, Mike Bennett, Mike Law, Nick Jackson, Paul London, Petey Williams, Sam Shields, Stone Cold ET, The Patriot, The Rockstar, The Sandman, Tony Nese, V. S. K., Wes Draven | FWE Rumble | |
 AWR Twisted Steel Tour '10 - Day 7
Nov 21st 2010 | The Sandman | def. | Justin Shape | | |
AWR Twisted Steel Tour '10 - Day 6
Nov 20th 2010 | The Sandman | def. | Justin Shape | | |
AWR Twisted Steel Tour '10 - Day 5
Nov 16th 2010 | The Sandman | def. | Justin Shape | | |
AWR Twisted Steel Tour '10 - Day 4
Nov 14th 2010 | The Sandman | def. | Justin Shape | | |
AWR Twisted Steel Tour '10 - Day 3
Nov 13th 2010 | The Sandman | def. | Paul Tracey | | |
AWR Twisted Steel Tour '10 - Day 2
Nov 11th 2010 | The Sandman | def. | Justin Shape | | |
AWR Twisted Steel Tour '10 - Day 1
Nov 10th 2010 | The Sandman | def. | Justin Shape | | |
N/A Legends of the Arena - ECW Reunion Show
Jun 27th 2009 | Sabu & The Sandman | def. | Justin Credible & Raven | referee: Terry Funk | |
The Sandman