| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT Venice Show
Nov 18th 2023 | Jade Gentile & Thea Hail | def. | Izzi Dame & Tatum Paxley | | |
WWE Main Event Taping
Nov 13th 2023 | Katana Chance | def. | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Orlando Show
Nov 11th 2023 | Izzi Dame & Tatum Paxley | def. | Anna Keefer & Tylynn Register | | |
NXT LVL UP #92 Taping
Nov 7th 2023 | Tatum Paxley | def. (pin) | Dani Palmer | | |
NXT Davenport Show
Oct 27th 2023 | Karmen Petrovic | def. | Anna Keefer, Arianna Grace, Blair Davenport, Elektra Lopez, Emma Maria Diaz, Fallon Henley, Jacy Jayne, Jade Gentile, Jaida Parker, Kennedy Cummins, Kiana James, Kiyah Saint, Lola Vice, Olena Sadovska, Roxanne Perez, Stevie Turner, Tatum Paxley, Thea Hail, Valentina Feroz | Halloween Costume Battle Royal | |
NXT Winter Haven Show
Oct 14th 2023 | Izzi Dame & Stevie Turner & Tatum Paxley | def. | Fallon Henley & Kelani Jordan & Kennedy Cummins | 6-person tag | |
NXT LVL UP #86 Taping
Sep 26th 2023 | Izzi Dame & Tatum Paxley | def. (pin) | Kelani Jordan & Valentina Feroz | | |
NXT LVL UP #83 Taping
Sep 12th 2023 | Jakara Jackson & Lash Legend | def. (pin) | Dani Palmer & Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Aug 12th 2023 | Kelani Jordan | def. | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT LVL UP #77 Taping
Aug 1st 2023 | Gigi Dolin | def. (pin) | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Lakeland Show
Jul 21st 2023 | Elektra Lopez & Lola Vice | def. | Izzi Dame & Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT TV #565 Taping
Jun 27th 2023 | Kelani Jordan | def. (pin) | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Jun 23rd 2023 | Blair Davenport & Tatum Paxley | def. | Brooklyn Barlow & Monika Klisara | | |
NXT LVL UP #73 Taping
Jun 20th 2023 | Fallon Henley | def. (pin) | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT TV #562
Jun 13th 2023 | Roxanne Perez | def. (pin) | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Dade City Show
Jun 9th 2023 | Blair Davenport & Kiana James & Tatum Paxley | def. | Dani Palmer & Gigi Dolin & Roxanne Perez | 6-person tag | |
NXT TV #561
Jun 6th 2023 | Thea Hail | def. | Brooklyn Barlow, Cora Jade, Dana Brooke, Elektra Lopez, Fallon Henley, Gigi Dolin, Jacy Jayne, Jakara Jackson, Kelani Jordan, Kiana James, Lash Legend, Lola Vice, Lyra Valkyria, Roxanne Perez, Tatum Paxley, Valentina Feroz, Yulisa Leon | battle royale | |
NXT Sebring Show
May 13th 2023 | Lash Legend & Trick Williams | def. | Javier Bernal & Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT TV #556
May 2nd 2023 | Dani Palmer | def. (pin) | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Apr 28th 2023 | Fallon Henley & Josh Briggs | def. (pin) | Javier Bernal & Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Gainesville Show
Apr 15th 2023 | Gigi Dolin | def. | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT TV #552
Apr 4th 2023 | Ivy Nile | def. (sub) | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT Sanford Show
Mar 25th 2023 | Ivy Nile | draw (DCO) | Tatum Paxley | | |
NXT TV #549 Taping
Mar 14th 2023 | Alba Fyre & Isla Dawn | def. (pin) | Ivy Nile & Tatum Paxley, Katana Chance & Kayden Carter | three-way tag | |
NXT Dade CIty Show
Mar 10th 2023 | Fallon Henley (c) & Kiana James (c) | def. | Alba Fyre & Isla Dawn, Ivy Nile & Tatum Paxley, Katana Chance & Kayden Carter | four-way tag | NXT Women's Tag Team Titles
|
Tatum Paxley