| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AAW Twisted Christmas 2009
Dec 26th 2009 | Jimmy Jacobs & Shane Hollister & Tyler Black | def. | Dave Crist & Jake Crist & Silas Young | 6-person tag | |
ROH Reverse the Curse
Dec 5th 2009 | Joey Ryan | def. | Rasche Brown, Sami Callihan, Shane Hollister | four corners survival | |
IWA-MS Wrestling With a Heart 2
Dec 4th 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Chuck Taylor, Prince Mustafa Ali, Ricochet | fatal 4-way | |
AAW Windy City Classic V
Nov 28th 2009 | Silas Young | def. | Jimmy Jacobs (c), Shane Hollister | three-way elimination | AAW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
AAW Windy City Classic V
Nov 28th 2009 | Dan Lawrence & Shane Hollister & Silas Young & Tim Donst | def. | Danny Daniels & Mason Beck & Nick Brubaker & Trik Davis | 8-person tag elimination | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '09 - Day 2
Nov 21st 2009 | T. J. Perkins | def. | Shane Hollister | | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '09 - Day 1
Nov 20th 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Flip Kendrick | | |
AAW Night of Vengeance
Oct 24th 2009 | Marek Brave & Shane Hollister | def. | Danny Daniels & Trik Davis | | |
AAW Nightmare on 26th Street 2009
Oct 17th 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Brett Gakiya, Dan Lawrence, Jordan McEntyre, Mason Beck, Nick Brubaker | 6-Way | |
AAW Hostile Intentions 2009
Sep 12th 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Danny Daniels | | |
AAW Us vs. Them
Sep 5th 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Nick Brubaker | | |
AAW Unleashed 2009
Aug 21st 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Marek Brave | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '09 - Day 2
Aug 15th 2009 | Trik Davis | def. | Shane Hollister | | |
IWA-MS The Night the Lights Went Out in Bellevue
Jul 25th 2009 | Mickie Knuckles & Sal Thomaselli & Shane Hollister | def. | Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter & Neil Diamond Cutter | 6-person tag | |
AAW Scars and Stripes 2009
Jul 11th 2009 | Arik Cannon (c) | def. | Shane Hollister | Stairway to Hell match | AAW Heritage Title
|
IWA-MS Battle of the Future Stars 2
Jul 10th 2009 | Donovan Cain & Marshe Rockett & Ryan Phoenix & Tim Donst | def. | Jason Hades & Jon Moxley & Ricochet & Shane Hollister | 8-person tag | |
IWA-MS Battle of the Future Stars 2
Jul 10th 2009 | Ricochet & Shane Hollister | def. | Jason Hades & Ryan Phoenix | | |
IWA-MS Battle of the Future Stars 2
Jul 10th 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Tim Donst | | |
IWA-MS Summer Scorcher 2009
Jun 20th 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Juice Robinson, Trik Davis | three-way | |
AAW Fate of Eight 2009
Jun 12th 2009 | Arik Cannon (c) | def. | Shane Hollister | | AAW Heritage Title
|
AAW Fate of Eight 2009
Jun 12th 2009 | Dash Phoenix (c) & Tweek Phoenix (c) | def. | Matt Cross & Shane Hollister | | AAW Tag Team Championship
|
IWA-MS Truth, Justice, and the IWA Way
Jun 6th 2009 | Ricochet | def. | Josh Raymond, Larry Sweeney, Marshe Rockett, Ryan Phoenix, Shane Hollister | 6-Way | |
IWA-MS A Cold Day In May
May 23rd 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Al Snow | | |
AAW Point of No Return 2009
May 1st 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2009 - Day 1
Apr 3rd 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Jason Hades, Ricochet | three-way | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2009 - Day 1
Apr 3rd 2009 | Jason Hades & Ricochet & Shane Hollister | def. | Chuck Taylor & Tim Donst & Trik Davis | 6-person tag | |
AAW 5 Year Anniversary Show
Mar 28th 2009 | Dash Phoenix (c) & Tweek Phoenix (c) | draw (time) | Matt Cross & Shane Hollister | | AAW Tag Team Championship
|
IWA-MS March Massacre 2009
Mar 20th 2009 | Jason Hades | def. | Shane Hollister | | |
GLCW/ICW/NWA Wisconsin Milwaukee Power Series
Feb 27th 2009 | The Russian | def. | Shane Hollister | | |
AAW My Bloody Valentine 2009
Feb 21st 2009 | Arik Cannon & Darin Corbin & Ryan Cruz | def. | Matt Cross & Shane Hollister & Tyler Black | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS February Fury 2009
Feb 6th 2009 | Jason Hades | def. | Ash, Carter Gray, Egotistico Fantastico, Prince Mustafa Ali, Shane Hollister, The Yellow Dog | 7-way elimination | |
AAW Path of Redemption 2009
Jan 24th 2009 | Arik Cannon (c) | def. | Matt Cross, Shane Hollister | three-way elimination | AAW Heritage Title
|
IWA-MS Cold Wave
Jan 23rd 2009 | Trik Davis | def. | Shane Hollister | | |
Shane Hollister during 2009