| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 IWA-MS Oolitic Show
Mar 7th 2004 | Delirious | def. | Nigel McGuinness, Steve Stone | three-way elimination | |
ROH At Our Best
Mar 13th 2004 | Jerry Lynn | def. (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | |
IWA-MS Salem Show
Mar 19th 2004 | Petey Williams | def. | Nigel McGuinness | | |
IWA-MS Lafayette Show
Mar 27th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. | Petey Williams | | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2004
Apr 9th 2004 | Delirious | def. | Nigel McGuinness | | |
IWA-MS Simply the Best V
Apr 10th 2004 | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | def. | Brad Bradley & Ryan Boz | | |
ROH Reborn: Stage 1
Apr 23rd 2004 | Matt Stryker | def. (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | |
ROH Reborn: Stage 2
Apr 24th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | Austin Aries, Jimmy Rave, Rocky Romero | four-way | |
IWA-MS You Gotta See This!
May 7th 2004 | B.J. Whitmer (c) | def. | Nigel McGuinness | | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
IWA-MS Meeting of the Minds
May 8th 2004 | Petey Williams | def. | Nigel McGuinness | | |
ROH Generation Next
May 22nd 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | Jimmy Jacobs | | |
IWA-MS A Shot of Southern Comfort
May 29th 2004 | CM Punk & Colt Cabana | def. | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | | |
ROH Reborn: Completion
Jul 17th 2004 | Doug Williams | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal, John Walters, Nigel McGuinness | four corners survival | |
IWA-MS Stylin' In The Summertime
Jul 31st 2004 | Brad Bradley (c) & Ryan Boz (c) | def. | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | | IWA:MS Tag Team Titles
|
ROH Testing The Limit
Aug 7th 2004 | John Walters | def. (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | |
IWA-MS An IWA Fairytale: The Hero vs. The Dragon
Aug 21st 2004 | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | def. | B.J. Whitmer & Danny Daniels | | |
ROH Glory By Honor III
Sep 11th 2004 | John Walters (c) | def. (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | ROH Pure Wrestling Title
|
IWA-MS An IWA Homecoming
Sep 16th 2004 | Alex Shelley & Roderick Strong | def. | Chris Hero & Nigel McGuinness | | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational '04: Night 1
Sep 17th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. (sub) | Claudio Castagnoli | | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational '04: Night 2
Sep 18th 2004 | Samoa Joe | def. (sub) | Nigel McGuinness | | |
ROH The Midnight Express Reunion
Oct 2nd 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | Homicide | | |
IWA-MS New Albany Show
Oct 7th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. | Chris Hero | | |
ROH Gold
Oct 15th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | Josh Daniels, Matt Stryker, Roderick Strong | four corners survival | |
ROH Joe Vs. Punk II
Oct 16th 2004 | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | B.J. Whitmer & Dan Maff | | |
IWA-MS Autumn Armageddon 2004
Oct 21st 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. | Chad Collyer | | |
IWA-MS Autumn Armageddon 2004
Oct 21st 2004 | Ace Steel & Chad Collyer | def. | Nigel McGuinness & Roderick Strong | | |
IWA-MS Revolution Strong Style Tournament 2004
Oct 22nd 2004 | Ace Steel & CM Punk & Danny Daniels & Matt Sydal | def. | Chris Candido & Claudio Castagnoli & Nigel McGuinness & Steve Stone | 8-person tag | |
IWA-MS 8th Anniversary Show: Dreams Do Come True
Oct 23rd 2004 | Austin Aries & Nigel McGuinness & Roderick Strong | def. | Ace Steel & Nate Webb & Samoa Joe | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS/NWA Wildside Wrestling Challenge
Oct 28th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. | Todd Sexton | | |
IWA-MS/NWA Wildside Wrestling Challenge
Oct 28th 2004 | Sal Rinauro & Shaun Tempers & Tank & Todd Sexton | def. | Ian Rotten & Jimmy Jacobs & Nate Webb & Nigel McGuinness | 8-person tag | |
IWA-MS Rensselaer Show
Nov 4th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. | Alex Shelley | | |
ROH Weekend of Thunder Night 1
Nov 5th 2004 | John Walters & Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Samoa Joe | | |
ROH Weekend of Thunder Night 2
Nov 6th 2004 | Chad Collyer | draw (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | WWF European Title
|
ROH All Star Extravaganza II
Dec 4th 2004 | Ricky Reyes (c) & Rocky Romero (c) | def. (pin) | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | | ROH World Tag Team Titles
|
IWA-MS/NWA No Limits Angels, Monsters & Toys (Oh My!!!)
Dec 11th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. | Ian Rotten | | |
IWA-MS A Merry Funkin' Christmas
Dec 12th 2004 | Nigel McGuinness | def. | Alex Shelley | "European Rules" | |
IWA-MS Rumble In Rensselear
Dec 18th 2004 | CM Punk (c) | def. | Nigel McGuinness | | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
ROH It All Begins
Jan 15th 2005 | Samoa Joe | def. (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | |
 wXw Joint@Venture - Day 1
Feb 11th 2005 | Ares | def. | Nigel McGuinness | | |
wXw Joint@Venture - Day 2
Feb 12th 2005 | Murat Bosporus | def. | Nigel McGuinness | | |
ROH Third Anniversary Celebration Pt. 2
Feb 25th 2005 | Colt Cabana | def. (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | |
ROH Third Anniversary Celebration Pt. 3
Feb 26th 2005 | Colt Cabana & Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | B.J. Whitmer & Dan Maff | | |
ROH Trios Tournament 2005
Mar 5th 2005 | Bryan Danielson & Samoa Joe & Vordell Walker | def. (pin) | James Gibson & Nigel McGuinness & Spanky | 6-person tag | |
ROH Back To Basics
Mar 12th 2005 | B.J. Whitmer (c) & Dan Maff (c) | def. (pin) | Colt Cabana & Nigel McGuinness | | ROH World Tag Team Titles
|
ROH Stalemate
Apr 16th 2005 | Samoa Joe | def. (pin) | Alex Shelley, Colt Cabana, Nigel McGuinness | four corners survival | |
ROH Manhattan Mayhem
May 7th 2005 | Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | Colt Cabana | | |
ROH The Final Showdown
May 13th 2005 | Colt Cabana & Doug Williams | def. (pin) | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | | |
ROH Nowhere To Run
May 14th 2005 | Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | Colt Cabana | | |
ROH New Frontiers
Jun 4th 2005 | Chad Collyer & Nigel McGuinness | def. (pin) | CM Punk & Colt Cabana | | |
ROH The Future Is Now
Jun 12th 2005 | Samoa Joe (c) | def. (pin) | Nigel McGuinness | | ROH Pure Wrestling Title
|
London, England, United Kingdom
Nigel McGuinness