| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 OTT/MWF Contenders in Italy
May 25th 2024 | Matthew Smyth (c) & Sean Guinness (c) | def. | Picchio & Ricky Eagle | | OTT Tag Team Titles
|
 OTT Spankdown
May 12th 2024 | Fabio & Martin Steers | def. (DQ) | Matthew Smyth (c) & Sean Guinness (c) | | OTT Tag Team Titles
|
OTT Contenders 23
Apr 28th 2024 | Matthew Smyth (c) & Sean Guinness (c) | def. | Joey Torres & Sito Sanchez | | OTT Tag Team Titles
|
OTT Supremacy
Apr 7th 2024 | Matthew Smyth & Sean Guinness | def. | Axel Jared & Cian Gallachini | | |
 OTT Gaff Party Belfast
Mar 3rd 2024 | Matthew Smyth (c) & Sean Guinness (c) | def. | Adam Maxted & Sammy D | | OTT Tag Team Titles
|
OTT Showdown In Sheriff Street
Feb 17th 2024 | Matthew Smyth & Sean Guinness | def. | Conn Kelly & Luke Frehill | | |
OTT Loco Rumble
Jan 20th 2024 | B-Cool | def. | Alex Grayson, Andy Steel, Aonghus Og McAnally, Big Bad Dirty Nicky, Bittersweet Josh, Boots Murphy, C. J. West, Calum Black, Captain Sexsea, Charles Crowley, Cian Noonan, Damien Corvin, Fabio, Goldenboy Santos, Grado, Ilija Zarkov, Jay, JB, Joe Cabray, Justy, Leyton Buzzard, Liamo, Logan Bryce, Man Like DeReiss, Martin Steers, Matthew Smyth, Noah Walker, Omari, Owen Richards, Paddy M, Ravie Davie, Sean Guinness, Terry Thatcher, The Sem, Tye Clodd, Workie | Rumble | |
OTT Loco Rumble
Jan 20th 2024 | Matthew Smyth & Sean Guinness | def. | B-Cool (c) & Danny Cross (c) | | OTT Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
OTT Now That's What I Call Christmas! - Day 1
Dec 16th 2023 | Matthew Smyth & Sean Guinness | def. | Trey Miguel & Zachary Wentz | | |
OTT Showdown In Milan
Nov 4th 2023 | Mirko Mori & Nico Inverardi | def. | Matthew Smyth & Sean Guinness | | |
Matthew Smyth