| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AJPW Giant Series 2023 - Day 9 ~ Hokkaido Edition
Nov 3rd 2023 | Atsuki Aoyagi & Rising HAYATO | draw (time) | Fuminori Abe & Jonathan Gresham | | |
AJPW Giant Series 2023 - Day 8 ~ Hokkaido Edition
Nov 2nd 2023 | Atsuki Aoyagi & Rising HAYATO | def. | Black Menso-re & Jonathan Gresham | | |
AJPW Giant Series 2023 - Day 7 ~ Hokkaido Edition
Nov 1st 2023 | Jonathan Gresham | def. | Fuminori Abe, Hikaru Sato | three-way | |
AJPW Giant Series 2023 - Day 6 ~ Hokkaido Edition
Oct 31st 2023 | Hokuto Omori & Jonathan Gresham & Minoru Suzuki | def. | Atsuki Aoyagi & Rising HAYATO & Shuji Ishikawa | 6-person tag | |
 Impact Wrestling Impact #1007 Taping
Oct 22nd 2023 | Alex Shelley (c) | def. | Jonathan Gresham | | Impact Wrestling World Title
|
Impact Wrestling Bound For Glory 2023
Oct 21st 2023 | Jordynne Grace | def. (pin) | Brian Myers, Bully Ray, Dirty Dango, Eddie Edwards, Eric Young, Frankie Kazarian, Gisele Shaw, Heath, Jake Something, Jody Threat, Joe Hendry, Johnny Swinger, Jonathan Gresham, Juventud Guerrera, Kenny King, KiLynn King, Matt Cardona, Rich Swann, Sonny Kiss | Call Your Shot Gauntlet Match | |
IWC Super Indy 22
Oct 7th 2023 | Anthony Catena | def. | Jonathan Gresham | | |
IWC Super Indy 22
Oct 7th 2023 | Jonathan Gresham | def. | Kevin Blackwood | | |
Prestige The Respect Issue
Sep 24th 2023 | Lee Moriarty | def. | Jonathan Gresham | | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #1002 Taping - Part 2
Sep 23rd 2023 | Jonathan Gresham | def. (pin) | Mike Bailey | | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #1000 Taping
Sep 9th 2023 | Chris Bey & Crazzy Steve & Moose & Yuya Uemura | def. | Alpha Bravo & Bhupinder Gujjar & Black Taurus & Brian Myers & Heath & Jai Vidal & Joe Hendry & John Skyler & Johnny Swinger & Jonathan Gresham & Kevin Knight & KUSHIDA & Laredo Kid & PCO & Sami Callihan & Steve Maclin | "feast or fired" | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #990 Taping
Jul 28th 2023 | Trey Miguel & Zachary Wentz | def. (pin) | Jonathan Gresham & Mike Bailey | | |
Prestige All Rise
Jul 23rd 2023 | Alex Shelley (c) | def. | Jonathan Gresham | | Prestige Championship
|
 Impact Wrestling Slammiversary 2023
Jul 15th 2023 | KUSHIDA | def. | Alan Angels & Jake Something & Jonathan Gresham & Kevin Knight & Mike Bailey | "Ultimate X" | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #987 Taping
Jun 24th 2023 | Ace Austin | def. | Angels, Jonathan Gresham, Trey Miguel | dark
four-way | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #986 Taping - Part 1
Jun 23rd 2023 | Jonathan Gresham | def. (sub) | Angels | | |
Battle Slam Heritage
Jun 16th 2023 | Jonathan Gresham | def. | Eli Isom | | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #984 Taping
Jun 10th 2023 | Jonathan Gresham & Mike Bailey | def. (pin) | Angels & Kon | | |
Impact Wrestling Against All Odds 2023
Jun 9th 2023 | Nick Aldis | def. (sub) | Bully Ray, Heath, Jonathan Gresham | four-way | |
Impact Wrestling Against All Odds 2023
Jun 9th 2023 | Bully Ray & Heath & Jonathan Gresham & Nick Aldis | def. (pin) | Mike Bailey & Moose & PCO & Rich Swann | 8-person tag | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #982 Taping
May 27th 2023 | Moose & Rich Swann | def. (pin) | Jonathan Gresham & Nick Aldis | | |
Impact Wrestling Under Siege 2023
May 26th 2023 | Alex Shelley | def. (pin) | Eddie Edwards, Frankie Kazarian, Jonathan Gresham, Moose, Yuya Uemura | 6-Way | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #979 Taping
Apr 29th 2023 | Alex Shelley & Jonathan Gresham & Yuya Uemura | def. (pin) | Eddie Edwards & Frankie Kazarian & Moose | 6-person tag | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #977 Taping
Apr 28th 2023 | Jonathan Gresham | def. (sub) | Mike Bailey | | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #975 Taping
Apr 17th 2023 | Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin & KUSHIDA | def. (pin) | Jonathan Gresham & Mike Bailey & Trey Miguel | 6-person tag | |
Jonathan Gresham