| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2013 - Day 2
May 25th 2013 | Ethan Page | def. | Johnny Gargano, Michael Elgin | three-way | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2013 - Day 2
May 25th 2013 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Kimber Lee | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2013 - Day 2
May 25th 2013 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Adam Cole | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2013 - Day 1
May 24th 2013 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Matt Cross | | |
 Smash (Canada) Stacked
May 19th 2013 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Tyson Dux | | |
CHIKARA Battle Not With Monsters
May 3rd 2013 | Frightmare & Hallowicked & Ultramantis Black | def. (pin) | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Johnny Gargano | 6-person tag | |
 wXw Hasta La Victoria Siempre Tour Finale
Apr 27th 2013 | Marty Scurll & Zack Sabre Jr. | def. | Johnny Gargano & Kevin Steen | | |
Dragon Gate USA Mercury Rising '13
Apr 6th 2013 | Johnny Gargano & Rich Swann & Ricochet | def. | CIMA & Eita & Tomahawk TT | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA The Shoulder of Pallas
Apr 6th 2013 | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Johnny Gargano & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Gran Akuma & Marty Jannetty & Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | 8-person tag | |
Dragon Gate USA Open the Ultimate Gate '13
Apr 5th 2013 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Shingo | | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
EVOLVE #19: Title Tournament
Apr 5th 2013 | Brian Kendrick & Johnny Gargano | def. | Drew Gulak & Orange Cassidy | | |
AIW Gauntlet For the Gold 8
Mar 29th 2013 | Colin Delaney | def. | ACH, Addy Starr, Allysin Kay, B.J. Whitmer, Bobby Beverly, Chris Dickinson, Dios Salvador, Ethan Page, Evan Gelistico, Gary Jay, Gregory Iron, Jack Verville, Jake Clemons, Jock Samson, Johnny Gargano, Josh Alexander, Josh Prohibition, Kodama, Louis Lyndon, Marion Fontaine, Matt Cross, Obariyon, Pierre Abernathy, Rickey Shane Page, Russ Myers, Super Oprah, T-Money, Tim Donst, Veda Scott | Battle Royal | |
AIW Gauntlet For the Gold 8
Mar 29th 2013 | Bobby Beverly & Rickey Shane Page | def. | Johnny Gargano & Josh Alexander | | |
PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 2
Mar 23rd 2013 | Chuck Taylor & Johnny Gargano | def. (pin) | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 1
Mar 22nd 2013 | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. | Chuck Taylor & Johnny Gargano | | |
CHIKARA The Watchmaker
Mar 9th 2013 | Dasher Hatfield & Gran Akuma & Green Ant & Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. | Blaster McMassive & Icarus & Johnny Gargano & Max Smashmaster & Sugar Dunkerton | 10-person tag | |
CHIKARA Just Shadows in the Fog
Mar 8th 2013 | Gran Akuma | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW Conspiracy Theory
Feb 9th 2013 | Eric Ryan (c) | def. | Johnny Gargano | | AIW Absolute Championship
|
Dragon Gate USA REVOLT! '13
Jan 27th 2013 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Jon Davis | no ropes | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
Dragon Gate USA Heat '13
Jan 27th 2013 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Brian Kendrick | | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
Dragon Gate USA Open the Golden Gate '13
Jan 26th 2013 | Jimmy Susumu & Ryo Saito | def. | Johnny Gargano & Rich Swann | | |
Dragon Gate USA Open The Golden Gate '13
Jan 25th 2013 | Jimmy Susumu & Ryo Saito | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano & Rich Swann | | |
Smash (Canada) Any Given Sunday
Jan 6th 2013 | Johnny Gargano & Scotty O'Shea | def. | Kevin Steen & Tyson Dux | | |
AIW The End of the World
Dec 21st 2012 | Eddie Kingston & Johnny Gargano | def. | Jimmy Jacobs & Rickey Shane Page | | |
EVOLVE #18: Gargano vs. Callihan
Dec 8th 2012 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Sami Callihan | | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
Johnny Gargano