| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 CHIKARA Battle Not With Monsters
May 3rd 2013 | Amasis | def. (sub) | The Shard | | |
 Alpha-1 Rehab
Apr 20th 2013 | Michael Elgin | def. | John Silver | | |
HOG/FTW The Showdown of the Century
Apr 12th 2013 | John Silver | def. | Anthony Gangone | | |
CHIKARA The Shoulder of Pallas
Apr 6th 2013 | Jushin Thunder Liger & Mike Quackenbush | def. | Jigsaw & The Shard | | |
PWS Super Card 2013 - Night 2
Apr 5th 2013 | Craig Steele | def. (pin) | John Silver | | |
PWS Super Card 2013 - Night 1
Apr 4th 2013 | Bonesaw | def. | Cassidy Reilly, Corey Havoc, Devious, Facade, Francis Kipland Stevens, Human Tornado, Hurricane Helms, Jobber Dustin, Jobber Justin, Joe Hardway, John Silver, Jon Phoenix, Kennedy Kendrick, Kevin Steen, Lance Anoa'i, Micah Taylor, Mo Sexton, Pat Buck, Simon Dean, Sonjay Dutt, Starman, The Big O, The Drunken Swashbuckler, Timmy Aiight, Trent Barreta, Unknown Participants | Battle Royal | |
Wresting is... Respect! - Boonton Show
Mar 24th 2013 | Green Ant | def. (sub) | The Shard | | |
PWS Proving Ground
Mar 15th 2013 | Devon Moore | def. | Bobby Wayward, Craven Varro, Dylan Thomas, John Silver, Kyle Brad, Lance Anoa'i | 7-way | |
CHIKARA The Watchmaker
Mar 9th 2013 | Jigsaw & The Shard | def. | Fire Ant & Mike Quackenbush | | |
CHIKARA Just Shadows in the Fog
Mar 8th 2013 | Icarus & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Kobald & Kodama, Green Ant & Mike Quackenbush, Jigsaw & The Shard | fatal 4-way elimination tag | |
CHIKARA While the Dawn is Breaking
Feb 10th 2013 | DeviANT & Jigsaw & The Shard | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked & Mike Quackenbush | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA All the Agents and Superhuman Crew
Feb 9th 2013 | Jigsaw & The Shard | def. | Icarus & Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA National Pro Wrestling Day 2013 - Evening Show
Feb 2nd 2013 | Apollyon & Tony Nese | def. | Alex Reynolds & John Silver | | |
Wresting is... Respect! - Rebirth
Jan 27th 2013 | Delirious | def. (pin) | The Shard | | |
PWS Student Clash
Jan 19th 2013 | John Silver | def. | M. D. Brocious | | |
Extreme Rising Card Subject to Change
Dec 29th 2012 | Brian XL & Matt Tremont | def. (pin) | Alex Reynolds & John Silver, Azrieal & Bandido Jr. | dark
triple-threat tag | |
PWS Fight-Mare Before Christmas
Dec 7th 2012 | Jerry Lynn | def. | A. R. Fox, Christian York, Craven Varro, John Silver, Lance Anoa'i, Rich Swann, The Big O | 8-way elimination | |
PWS Bombshell Ladies of Wrestling Event #2
Dec 6th 2012 | John Silver | def. | Alicia | | |
CHIKARA Under the Hood
Dec 2nd 2012 | DeviANT & Jigsaw & Soldier Ant & The Shard | def. | AssailANT & Fire Ant & Green Ant & Mike Quackenbush | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA The Cibernetico Rises
Nov 18th 2012 | The Shard | def. | Fire Ant | | |
CHIKARA A Piece of the Action
Nov 11th 2012 | DeviANT & The Shard | def. | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | | |
CHIKARA Zelda the Great
Nov 10th 2012 | El Generico | def. | The Shard | | |
PWS The Show Must Go On
Nov 9th 2012 | Joe Hardway & Mo Sexton & The Big O | def. | Jobber Dustin & Jobber Justin & John Silver | 6-person tag | |
PWS House Party 5: Not Starring Kid N Play
Oct 12th 2012 | Devon Moore | def. | John Silver, Lance Anoa'i, Lucifer Darksyde, Rich Swann, The Dynamic Sensation | 6-Way | |
CHIKARA The Zodiac Crimes
Oct 7th 2012 | Fire Ant & Green Ant & Hallowicked & Mike Quackenbush & Ultramantis Black | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Kodama & Obariyon & The Shard | 10-person tag | |
John Silver