| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WWE Monday Night Raw
Jan 2nd 2012 | Skip Sheffield | def. | Michael McGillicutty | dark
| |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #43
Jan 3rd 2012 | Alex Riley | def. | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jan 6th 2012 | Alex Riley & Mason Ryan | def. (pin) | Antonio Cesaro & Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jan 7th 2012 | Alex Riley & Mason Ryan | def. (pin) | Antonio Cesaro & Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jan 8th 2012 | Alex Riley & Mason Ryan | def. (pin) | Antonio Cesaro & Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Jan 9th 2012 | Evan Bourne | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Jan 23rd 2012 | Kofi Kingston | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania (Raw)
Feb 3rd 2012 | Brodus Clay | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania (Raw)
Feb 4th 2012 | Brodus Clay | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania (Raw)
Feb 5th 2012 | Brodus Clay | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Feb 6th 2012 | Epico & Primo | def. (pin) | JTG & Michael McGillicutty | | |
 WWE WWE Live - World Tour (Raw)
Feb 9th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | David Otunga | | |
WWE WWE Live - World Tour (Raw)
Feb 10th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Drew McIntyre | | |
WWE WWE Live - World Tour (Raw)
Feb 11th 2012 | Santino Marella | def. | Alex Riley, David Otunga, Dolph Ziggler, Drew McIntyre, Epico, Kofi Kingston, Mason Ryan, Michael McGillicutty, Primo | Battle Royal | |
WWE WWE Live - World Tour (Raw)
Feb 11th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | David Otunga | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #49
Feb 14th 2012 | Percy Watson | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Feb 14th 2012 | Santino Marella | def. | Alex Riley, Camacho, Curt Hawkins, Darren Young, David Otunga, Derrick Bateman, Drew McIntyre, Epico, Ezekiel Jackson, Heath Slater, Hunico, Jey Uso, Jimmy Uso, Jinder Mahal, Johnny Curtis, Justin Gabriel, Michael McGillicutty, Percy Watson, Primo, Ted DiBiase Jr., Titus O'Neil, Tyler Reks, Tyson Kidd, Yoshi Tatsu | Battle Royal | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Feb 20th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Alex Riley | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #51
Feb 28th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Tyson Kidd | | |
 WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania (Raw)
Mar 2nd 2012 | Brodus Clay | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania (Raw)
Mar 3rd 2012 | Brodus Clay | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live - Road To WrestleMania (Raw)
Mar 4th 2012 | Brodus Clay | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Mar 12th 2012 | Seth Rollins | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | dark
| |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Mar 19th 2012 | Brodus Clay | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | dark
| |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #54
Mar 20th 2012 | Tyson Kidd | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #56
Apr 3rd 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Derrick Bateman | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #57
Apr 10th 2012 | Tyson Kidd | def. | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Apr 30th 2012 | Zack Ryder | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #60
May 1st 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Percy Watson | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #61
May 8th 2012 | Percy Watson & Tyson Kidd | def. (pin) | Johnny Curtis & Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #62
May 15th 2012 | Tyson Kidd | def. (pin) | Derrick Bateman, Michael McGillicutty | triple-threat | |
NXT TV Taping #1
May 17th 2012 | Tyson Kidd | def. (sub) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
NXT TV Taping #3
May 17th 2012 | Camacho & Hunico & Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Bo Dallas & Seth Rollins & Tyson Kidd | 6-person tag | |
WWE Over the Limit '12
May 20th 2012 | Christian | def. | Alex Riley, Curt Hawkins, Darren Young, David Otunga, Drew McIntyre, Ezekiel Jackson, Heath Slater, Jey Uso, Jimmy Uso, Jinder Mahal, JTG, Michael McGillicutty, The Great Khali, The Miz, Titus O'Neil, Tyler Reks, Tyson Kidd, William Regal, Yoshi Tatsu | "People Power" battle royale | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
May 21st 2012 | Kofi Kingston & R-Truth | def. (pin) | JTG & Michael McGillicutty | | |
 WWE WWE Live (Raw)
May 24th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Curt Hawkins | | |
 WWE WWE Live (Raw)
May 25th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Curt Hawkins | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
May 26th 2012 | Michael McGillicutty | def. (pin) | Curt Hawkins | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #64
May 29th 2012 | Derrick Bateman & Justin Gabriel & Percy Watson | def. (pin) | Johnny Curtis & JTG & Michael McGillicutty | 6-person tag | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jun 1st 2012 | Seth Rollins | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jun 2nd 2012 | Seth Rollins | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jun 3rd 2012 | Seth Rollins | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
 WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jun 6th 2012 | Mason Ryan | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jun 7th 2012 | Mason Ryan | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jun 8th 2012 | Mason Ryan | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Jun 9th 2012 | Mason Ryan | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Jun 11th 2012 | Zack Ryder | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #66
Jun 12th 2012 | Jey Uso & Jimmy Uso | def. (pin) | Johnny Curtis & Michael McGillicutty | | |
NXT TV Taping #6
Jun 13th 2012 | Johnny Curtis & Michael McGillicutty | def. | Bo Dallas & Derrick Bateman | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Jun 25th 2012 | Kofi Kingston | def. (pin) | Michael McGillicutty | | |
Joe Hennig during 2012