| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 2
Sep 26th 2009 | Samoa Joe (c) | def. | Jay Lethal | | TNA X-Division Title
|
TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 1
Sep 25th 2009 | Jay Lethal | def. | Sheik Abdul Bashir | | |
 TNA iMPACT! Taping
Sep 22nd 2009 | The Amazing Red | def. | Consequences Creed, Jay Lethal, Kiyoshi, Sheik Abdul Bashir | 5-way ladder | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Sep 1st 2009 | D'Angelo Dinero | def. | Jay Lethal | | |
TNA Hard Justice '09
Aug 16th 2009 | Christopher Daniels | def. | Alex Shelley, Chris Sabin, Consequences Creed, D'Angelo Dinero, Jay Lethal, Suicide, The Amazing Red | "Steel Asylum" | |
JAPW Caged Destiny
Jun 27th 2009 | Dan Maff | def. | Jay Lethal (c) | steel cage | JAPW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jun 24th 2009 | Jay Lethal | draw (NC) | Jethro Holliday | | |
TNA Slammiversary '09
Jun 21st 2009 | Suicide (c) | def. | Alex Shelley, Chris Sabin, Consequences Creed, Jay Lethal | "King of the Mountain" (5-way) | TNA X-Division Title
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
May 27th 2009 | Brother Devon & Brother Ray & James Storm & Robert Roode | def. | Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin & Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal | 8-person tag | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
May 27th 2009 | Alex Shelley & Jay Lethal | def. | Brother Devon & Brother Ray | | |
TNA Sacrifice '09
May 24th 2009 | Consequences Creed & Eric Young & Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin & Sheik Abdul Bashir | 6-person tag | |
JAPW Double Header - Evening Show
May 9th 2009 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. | Azrieal, Homicide, Teddy Hart | four-way | JAPW Heavyweight Title
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
May 5th 2009 | Christopher Daniels & Suicide | def. | Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin, Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal | three-way tag | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Apr 22nd 2009 | Consequences Creed & Eric Young & Jay Lethal | def. | Kiyoshi & Tetsuya Naito & Yujiro | 6-person tag | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Apr 21st 2009 | James Storm & Robert Roode | def. | Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal | | |
TNA Lockdown '09
Apr 19th 2009 | Suicide (c) | def. | Consequences Creed, Jay Lethal, Kiyoshi, Sheik Abdul Bashir | Six Sides of Steel: Xscape (5-way) | TNA X-Division Title
|
JAPW International Invasion
Apr 18th 2009 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. | Dan Maff | | JAPW Heavyweight Title
|
WSU/NWS King & Queen of the Ring Tournament 2009
Apr 11th 2009 | Jay Lethal & Miss April | def. | Danny Demanto & Jana | | |
WSU/NWS King & Queen of the Ring Tournament 2009
Apr 11th 2009 | Jay Lethal & Miss April | def. | Annie Social & Bison Bravado | | |
WSU/NWS King & Queen of the Ring Tournament 2009
Apr 11th 2009 | Jay Lethal & Miss April | def. | Helter Skelter & Trixie Lynn | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Mar 30th 2009 | Kiyoshi & Sheik Abdul Bashir & Tetsuya Naito & Yujiro | def. (pin) | Consequences Creed & Hernandez & Homicide & Jay Lethal | 8-person tag | |
JAPW Unfinished Business
Mar 28th 2009 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. | Dan Maff | | JAPW Heavyweight Title
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Mar 17th 2009 | Samoa Joe | def. | A.J. Styles, Abyss, Alex Shelley, Booker T., Chris Sabin, Consequences Creed, Eric Young, Hernandez, Homicide, Jay Lethal, Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle, Matt Morgan, Rhino, Scott Steiner, Shane Sewell, Sheik Abdul Bashir, Tetsuya Naito, Yujiro | Gauntlet (20 entrants) | |
TNA Destination X '09
Mar 15th 2009 | Suicide | def. | Alex Shelley (c), Chris Sabin, Consequences Creed, Jay Lethal | "Ultimate X" | TNA X-Division Title
(title change) |
JAPW Jersey City Rumble 2009
Feb 28th 2009 | Jay Lethal | def. | Kenny Omega (c) | | JAPW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
Jay Lethal