| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 FWE Welcome to the Rumble 2
Jun 21st 2013 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Alex Reynolds, Bandido Jr., Chris Masters, Chris Rockwell, Damien Darling, E. J. Risk, Exerguy JP, Exerguy M3, Jason Gotti, Jay Lethal, Jigsaw, Jimmy Wang Yang, Joey Ace, Johnny Knockout, Jorge Santi, Matt Jackson, Matt Striker, Mike Bennett, Mike Law, Nick Jackson, Paul London, Petey Williams, Sam Shields, Stone Cold ET, The Patriot, The Rockstar, The Sandman, Tony Nese, V. S. K., Wes Draven | FWE Rumble | |
ROH Live and Let Die
Jun 8th 2013 | Cliff Compton & Jimmy Jacobs & Rhett Titus | def. | B.J. Whitmer & Jay Lethal & Michael Elgin | 6-person tag | |
ROH Honor in the Heart of Texas
Jun 1st 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | ACH | | |
ROH Relentless
May 18th 2013 | Caprice Coleman & Cedric Alexander & Jay Lethal | def. | Bobby Fish & Kyle O'Reilly & Matt Taven | 6-person tag | |
ROH Dragon's Reign
May 11th 2013 | Jimmy Jacobs | def. | Jay Lethal | no disqualification | |
 ROH TV Tapings
May 5th 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | B.J. Whitmer, Mike Bennett | triple-threat | |
ROH TV Tapings
May 5th 2013 | Jimmy Jacobs | def. | Jay Lethal | | |
ROH Border Wars '13
May 4th 2013 | Cliff Compton & Jimmy Jacobs | def. | Jay Lethal & Michael Elgin | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Apr 6th 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Rhett Titus | | |
ROH Supercard of Honor VII
Apr 4th 2013 | Michael Elgin | def. | Jay Lethal | | |
ROH WAR
Mar 30th 2013 | ACH | def. | Jay Lethal, Matt Taven, Roderick Strong | four-way | |
PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 2
Mar 23rd 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Willie Mack | | |
PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 1
Mar 22nd 2013 | Eddie Edwards | def. (sub) | Jay Lethal | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 3rd 2013 | Matt Hardy & Rhino & Steve Corino | def. | B.J. Whitmer & Jay Lethal & Michael Elgin | 6-person tag | |
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 3rd 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Roderick Strong | | |
ROH 11th Anniversary Show
Mar 2nd 2013 | Kevin Steen (c) | def. | Jay Lethal | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
ROH Honor vs. Evil
Feb 16th 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Tadarius Thomas | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Feb 2nd 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Jimmy Jacobs | | |
ROH Defy or Deny 2
Jan 19th 2013 | Jimmy Jacobs & Rhino & Steve Corino | def. | Jay Briscoe & Jay Lethal & Mark Briscoe | 6-person tag | |
ROH The Hunt for Gold
Jan 18th 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Steve Corino | | |
ROH Final Battle '12: Doomsday
Dec 16th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Rhino | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Nov 3rd 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Chris Silvio | | |
ROH Glory by Honor XI
Oct 13th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Davey Richards | | |
ROH Killer Instinct
Oct 6th 2012 | Kevin Steen (c) | draw (NC) | Jay Lethal | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
FWE Back 2 Brooklyn
Oct 5th 2012 | Brian Kendrick & Jay Lethal & Paul London | def. | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson & Petey Williams | 6-person tag | |
ROH TV Tapings
Sep 22nd 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Adam Cole, Davey Richards, Michael Elgin, Mike Mondo, Roderick Strong | 6-way elimination | |
ROH TV Tapings
Sep 22nd 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Q. T. Marshall | | |
ROH Death Before Dishonor X: State of Emergency
Sep 15th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Homicide | | |
ROH Caged Hostility
Sep 8th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Adam Page | | |
ROH Boiling Point '12
Aug 11th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Tommaso Ciampa | 2 out of 3 falls | |
ROH TV Tapings
Aug 3rd 2012 | Jay Lethal | draw (NC) | Matt Taven | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Aug 3rd 2012 | Mike Mondo | def. | Jay Lethal, Mike Bennett, Roderick Strong, T. J. Perkins, Tommaso Ciampa | "Six Man Mayhem" | |
FWE X
Jul 28th 2012 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Brian Kendrick, Carlito, Jay Lethal (c) | fatal 4-way elimination | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
ROH Brew City Beatdown
Jul 14th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Mike Mondo | | |
ROH Live Strong
Jun 30th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Kyle O'Reilly | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Jun 29th 2012 | Jay Lethal & Kenny King & Rhett Titus | def. | Jimmy Jacobs & Kevin Steen & Steve Corino | 6-person tag | |
ROH Best in the World '12: Hostage Crisis
Jun 24th 2012 | Roderick Strong (c) | def. | Jay Lethal, Tommaso Ciampa | three-way | ROH World Television Title
|
ROH The Nightmare Begins
Jun 15th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
FWE Dysfunctional Family
Jun 9th 2012 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. | Carlito, Tommy Dreamer | three-way hardcore | FWE Heavyweight Championship
|
PWS Five Year Anniversary Weekend - Night 2
Jun 2nd 2012 | Big Van Vader & Too Cold Scorpio | def. | Devon Moore & Jay Lethal | | |
ROH Battle of Richmond
May 19th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Mike Mondo | | |
ROH TV Tapings
May 18th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Chris Silvio | | |
ROH TV Tapings
May 18th 2012 | Roderick Strong | def. (pin) | Adam Cole, Jay Lethal, Mike Bennett | dark
four corners | |
ROH Border Wars
May 12th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Tommaso Ciampa | | |
HOG High Intensity
May 5th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Brian XL | | |
PWS Refuse to Lose 2012
May 4th 2012 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Jay Lethal | | PWS Heavyweight Title
|
ROH Rising Above 2012
Apr 29th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Roderick Strong | 2 out of 3 falls | |
ROH Unity
Apr 28th 2012 | Fire Ant & Green Ant & Soldier Ant | def. | Adam Cole & Jay Lethal & T. J. Perkins | 6-person tag lucha rules | |
ROH TV Tapings
Apr 7th 2012 | Grizzly Redwood & Jay Lethal & Kamel Dickinson | def. (DQ) | Michael Elgin | handicap tag | |
ROH TV Tapings
Apr 7th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Ricky Reyes | | |
Jay Lethal