| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH Supercard of Honor VII
Apr 4th 2013 | Michael Elgin | def. | Jay Lethal | | |
ROH WAR
Mar 30th 2013 | ACH | def. | Jay Lethal, Matt Taven, Roderick Strong | four-way | |
PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 2
Mar 23rd 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Willie Mack | | |
PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 1
Mar 22nd 2013 | Eddie Edwards | def. (sub) | Jay Lethal | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 3rd 2013 | Matt Hardy & Rhino & Steve Corino | def. | B.J. Whitmer & Jay Lethal & Michael Elgin | 6-person tag | |
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 3rd 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Roderick Strong | | |
ROH 11th Anniversary Show
Mar 2nd 2013 | Kevin Steen (c) | def. | Jay Lethal | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
ROH Honor vs. Evil
Feb 16th 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Tadarius Thomas | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Feb 2nd 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Jimmy Jacobs | | |
ROH Defy or Deny 2
Jan 19th 2013 | Jimmy Jacobs & Rhino & Steve Corino | def. | Jay Briscoe & Jay Lethal & Mark Briscoe | 6-person tag | |
ROH The Hunt for Gold
Jan 18th 2013 | Jay Lethal | def. | Steve Corino | | |
ROH Final Battle '12: Doomsday
Dec 16th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Rhino | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Nov 3rd 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Chris Silvio | | |
 ROH Glory by Honor XI
Oct 13th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Davey Richards | | |
ROH Killer Instinct
Oct 6th 2012 | Kevin Steen (c) | draw (NC) | Jay Lethal | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
FWE Back 2 Brooklyn
Oct 5th 2012 | Brian Kendrick & Jay Lethal & Paul London | def. | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson & Petey Williams | 6-person tag | |
ROH TV Tapings
Sep 22nd 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Adam Cole, Davey Richards, Michael Elgin, Mike Mondo, Roderick Strong | 6-way elimination | |
ROH TV Tapings
Sep 22nd 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Q. T. Marshall | | |
ROH Death Before Dishonor X: State of Emergency
Sep 15th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Homicide | | |
ROH Caged Hostility
Sep 8th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Adam Page | | |
ROH Boiling Point '12
Aug 11th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Tommaso Ciampa | 2 out of 3 falls | |
ROH TV Tapings
Aug 3rd 2012 | Jay Lethal | draw (NC) | Matt Taven | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Aug 3rd 2012 | Mike Mondo | def. | Jay Lethal, Mike Bennett, Roderick Strong, T. J. Perkins, Tommaso Ciampa | "Six Man Mayhem" | |
FWE X
Jul 28th 2012 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Brian Kendrick, Carlito, Jay Lethal (c) | fatal 4-way elimination | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
ROH Brew City Beatdown
Jul 14th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Mike Mondo | | |
ROH Live Strong
Jun 30th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Kyle O'Reilly | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Jun 29th 2012 | Jay Lethal & Kenny King & Rhett Titus | def. | Jimmy Jacobs & Kevin Steen & Steve Corino | 6-person tag | |
ROH Best in the World '12: Hostage Crisis
Jun 24th 2012 | Roderick Strong (c) | def. | Jay Lethal, Tommaso Ciampa | three-way | ROH World Television Title
|
ROH The Nightmare Begins
Jun 15th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
FWE Dysfunctional Family
Jun 9th 2012 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. | Carlito, Tommy Dreamer | three-way hardcore | FWE Heavyweight Championship
|
PWS Five Year Anniversary Weekend - Night 2
Jun 2nd 2012 | Big Van Vader & Too Cold Scorpio | def. | Devon Moore & Jay Lethal | | |
ROH Battle of Richmond
May 19th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Mike Mondo | | |
ROH TV Tapings
May 18th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Chris Silvio | | |
ROH TV Tapings
May 18th 2012 | Roderick Strong | def. (pin) | Adam Cole, Jay Lethal, Mike Bennett | dark
four corners | |
ROH Border Wars
May 12th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Tommaso Ciampa | | |
HOG High Intensity
May 5th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Brian XL | | |
PWS Refuse to Lose 2012
May 4th 2012 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Jay Lethal | | PWS Heavyweight Title
|
ROH Rising Above 2012
Apr 29th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Roderick Strong | 2 out of 3 falls | |
ROH Unity
Apr 28th 2012 | Fire Ant & Green Ant & Soldier Ant | def. | Adam Cole & Jay Lethal & T. J. Perkins | 6-person tag lucha rules | |
ROH TV Tapings
Apr 7th 2012 | Grizzly Redwood & Jay Lethal & Kamel Dickinson | def. (DQ) | Michael Elgin | handicap tag | |
ROH TV Tapings
Apr 7th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Ricky Reyes | | |
ROH Showdown in the Sun - Day 2
Mar 31st 2012 | Roderick Strong | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal (c) | | ROH World Television Title
(title change) |
ROH Showdown in the Sun - Day 1
Mar 30th 2012 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. (pin) | Kyle O'Reilly | | ROH World Television Title
|
FWE Welcome to the Rumble
Mar 24th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | Eric Young (c) | | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
FWE Welcome to the Rumble
Mar 24th 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. | A. J. Pann, Azrieal, Bandido Jr., Brian Kendrick, Charlie Haas, Chris Rockwell, Damien Darling, E. J. Risk, Eric Young, Fake Damien Darling, Hawaii Allen, Jason Gotti, Joey Ace, K-Fresh, Mike Bennett, Sam Shields, Shawn Daivari, Sonjay Dutt, V. S. K., Wes Draven, Xander Page | FWE Rumble | |
FWE Welcome to the Rumble
Mar 24th 2012 | Damien Darling | def. | Jay Lethal (c) | | FWE Tri-Borough Title
(title change) |
PWS Super Card 2012
Mar 9th 2012 | Matt Hardy | def. | Jay Lethal | | |
ROH 10th Anniversary Show
Mar 4th 2012 | Jay Lethal (c) | draw (time) | Tommaso Ciampa | | ROH World Television Title
|
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 3rd 2012 | Tommaso Ciampa | def. (pin) | Adam Cole, Jay Lethal, Mike Bennett | four-way elimination | |
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 3rd 2012 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Roderick Strong | | |
Jay Lethal