| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016 - TV Tapings
Jan 9th 2016 | Leon St. Giovanni | def. (pin) | David Starr, Foxx Vinyer, Ken Phoenix | dark
four-way | |
 wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: Fulda
Jan 30th 2016 | Big Daddy Walter | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw Dead End XV
Feb 6th 2016 | Big Daddy Walter | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: Köln
Feb 13th 2016 | David Starr | def. | Marius Al-Ani | | |
wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: Bielefeld
Feb 20th 2016 | Axel Dieter Jr. | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: Gotha
Feb 26th 2016 | John Klinger | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: Halle (Saale)
Feb 27th 2016 | David Starr | def. | Da Mack | | |
wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: Stuttgart
Mar 4th 2016 | The Rotation | def. | David Starr, Tyler Bate | three-way | |
wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: München
Mar 5th 2016 | Tyler Bate | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw More Than Wrestling Tour 2016: Karlsruhe
Mar 6th 2016 | Da Mack | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw The Inner Circle
Mar 10th 2016 | Zack Sabre Jr. | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw 16 Carat Gold 2016 - Day 1
Mar 11th 2016 | David Starr | def. (pin) | Aaron Insane, Mike Schwarz, Tyler Bate | dark
four-way | |
wXw AMBITION 7
Mar 12th 2016 | Sasa Keel | def. (KO) | David Starr | | |
wXw 16 Carat Gold 2016 - Day 2
Mar 12th 2016 | David Starr & Shane Strickland | def. (pin) | Big Daddy Walter & Da Mack | | |
wXw 16 Carat Gold 2016 - Day 3
Mar 13th 2016 | Ilja Dragunov (c) & Julian Nero (c) | def. (pin) | David Starr & Shane Strickland | | wXw World Tag Team Titles
|
CZW Proving Grounds 2016
Mar 26th 2016 | Lio Rush | def. | Dave Crist, David Starr, Joey Janela (c) | four-way | CZW Wired TV Title
(title change) |
CZW Welcome to the Combat Zone
Apr 1st 2016 | Dave Crist | def. | David Starr | | |
CZW Best of the Best 15
Apr 9th 2016 | David Starr | def. (pin) | Dave Crist, Dezmond Xavier | three-way | |
CZW Best of the Best 15
Apr 9th 2016 | David Starr | def. (pin) | Shane Strickland | | |
CZW Best of the Best 15
Apr 9th 2016 | Jonathan Gresham | def. (sub) | David Starr | | |
HOG Unfinished Business
May 6th 2016 | Isiah Kassidy (c) & Marq Quen (c) | def. | David Starr & Shane Strickland | | HOG Tag Team Titles
|
CZW Prelude to Violence 2016
May 14th 2016 | Dave Crist | def. (pin) | David Starr | | |
Beyond C5 - A Fundraiser for Brandon Watts
May 29th 2016 | David Starr | draw (DCO) | Joey Janela | grudge match | |
PWS Super Card 2016
Jun 11th 2016 | Andy Harner | def. (pin) | Brett Gakiya, C. J. Esparza, David Starr, Facade, Tony Deppen | 6-Way | PWS Suicidal 6-Way Title
(title change) |
Beyond/HOG HOGxBEYOND
Jun 17th 2016 | David Starr | def. | Ken Broadway, Smiley, Tracy Williams | four-way | |
Beyond Ripped Off in the Prime of Life
Jun 26th 2016 | Tommaso Ciampa | def. | David Starr | | |
 Alpha-1 The Purge
Jul 3rd 2016 | Kobe Durst | def. | David Starr | | |
IWA-MS The Star Spangled Spectacular
Jul 7th 2016 | J. J. Garrett | def. | David Starr | | |
CZW/Freelance Freelance Wrestling vs. CZW
Jul 8th 2016 | Arik Cannon & Chris Castro & Sally Stitches & The Space Monkey | def. (pin) | Brittany Blake & Conor Claxton & David Starr & Joe Gacy | 8-person tag | |
CZW New Heights 2016
Jul 9th 2016 | Dave Crist | def. | David Starr | 2 out of 3 falls | |
TNA Impact! Tapings
Jul 13th 2016 | Moose | def. | David Starr | | |
TNA One Night Only: X-Travaganza 2016 Taping - Part 2
Jul 14th 2016 | Suicide | def. | David Starr | | |
ROH Aftershock Tour 2016 - TV Tapings
Jul 16th 2016 | Cheeseburger | draw (NC) | David Starr, Joey Daddiego, Tim Hughes | four-way | |
Beyond Americanrana 2016
Jul 31st 2016 | David Starr | def. (sub) | Johnny Gargano | | |
Beyond Battle of Who Could Care Less
Aug 28th 2016 | David Starr | def. (pin) | Eddie Edwards | | |
CZW Down With The Sickness 2016
Sep 10th 2016 | David Starr | def. | Dave Crist | no disqualification | |
EVOLVE #69
Sep 11th 2016 | Ethan Page | def. (pin) | David Starr | | |
wXw The Inner Circle 2
Sep 29th 2016 | Timothy Thatcher (c) | def. | David Starr | | EVOLVE Title
|
wXw World Tag Team League 2016 - Day 1
Sep 30th 2016 | Angélico & Jack Evans | def. | David Starr & Shane Strickland | | |
wXw World Tag Team League 2016 - Day 2
Oct 1st 2016 | David Starr & Shane Strickland | def. | Timothy Thatcher & WALTER | | |
wXw World Tag Team League 2016 - Day 3
Oct 2nd 2016 | David Starr & Shane Strickland | def. | Trent Seven & Tyler Bate | | |
wXw World Tag Team League 2016 - Day 3
Oct 2nd 2016 | Timothy Thatcher & WALTER | def. | David Starr & Shane Strickland | | wXw World Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
 wXw Shotgun Live Tour: Basel
Oct 7th 2016 | David Starr | def. | Shane Strickland | | |
wXw Shotgun Live Tour: Basel
Oct 7th 2016 | Da Mack | def. | David Starr, Julian Nero | three-way | |
wXw Shotgun Live Tour: Borken
Oct 14th 2016 | David Starr (c) & Shane Strickland (c) | def. | Dirty Dragan & Ilja Dragunov | | wXw World Tag Team Titles
|
wXw Shotgun Live Tour: Bielefeld
Oct 15th 2016 | WALTER | def. | David Starr | | |
wXw Shotgun Live Tour: Stuttgart
Oct 21st 2016 | David Starr | def. | Marius Al-Ani | | |
wXw Broken Rules XVI
Oct 22nd 2016 | Absolute Andy & Marius Al-Ani | def. | David Starr & Lio Rush | TLC (2 vs. 2) | wXw World Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
wXw Shotgun Live Tour: Karlsruhe
Oct 23rd 2016 | Jurn Simmons (c) | def. | David Starr | | wXw Unified World Title
|
 RevPro Live in Portsmouth 6
Oct 30th 2016 | Trent Seven | def. | David Starr | | |
David Starr during 2016