| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Smash (Canada)/PROGRESS Smash vs. PROGRESS
Aug 7th 2019 | Daniel Garcia & Idris Abraham & Joe Coleman & John Greed | def. | Chris Brookes & David Starr & Paul Robinson & Travis Banks | 8-person tag | |
 RevPro Live at the Cockpit 44
Aug 4th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Senza Volto | | |
 wXw Shortcut To The Top 2019
Aug 3rd 2019 | Timothy Thatcher | def. | Absolute Andy, Alpha Kevin, Avalanche, Chris Brookes, David Starr, El Lindaman, Emil Sitoci, Francis Kaspin, Ilja Dragunov, Ivan Kiev, Jay Skillet, Julian Pace, Jurn Simmons, Kyle Fletcher, Leon van Gasteren, Levaniel, Maggot, Marius Al-Ani, Mark Davis, Mike Schwarz, Norman Harras, Oliver Carter, Prince Ahura, Sha Samuels, Shigehiro Irie, T-Hawk, The Rotation, Vinny Vortex, WALTER | Shortcut to the Top Rumble | |
 Beyond Americanrana 2019
Jul 28th 2019 | Joey Janela | def. | David Starr | 60 minute Ironman | |
PWG Sixteen
Jul 26th 2019 | Brody King | def. | David Starr | | |
WrestlePro Shotgun Thursday Night
Jul 25th 2019 | Bobby Wayward | def. | David Starr | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 17
Jul 24th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Wheeler YUTA | | |
RevPro Live at the Cockpit 43
Jul 7th 2019 | PAC | def. | David Starr | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 91: Prog On The Tyne
Jul 6th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Brent Banks | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 90: The Lonesome Death of the One-Man Cabaret Act
Jun 30th 2019 | David Starr & The OJMO | def. | Shigehiro Irie & WALTER | | |
Defiant Built to Destroy 2019
Jun 29th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Rampage (c) | no disqualification | Defiant World Title
(title change) |
 OTT WrestleRama 3
Jun 23rd 2019 | WALTER | def. (ref) | David Starr | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 11
Jun 12th 2019 | David Starr & Eddie Kingston | def. | Bear Beefcake & Bear Bronson | | |
Beyond Secret Show
Jun 9th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Solo Darling | | |
RevPro Live at the Cockpit 42
Jun 2nd 2019 | David Starr | def. | Rickey Shane Page | | |
Defiant Loaded TV Tapings
Jun 1st 2019 | David Starr | def. | Rory Coyle | Video Store Massacre Match | |
OTT Live in Belfast: Banjaxed
May 26th 2019 | David Starr | def. (ref) | Sean Guinness | | |
Defiant No Regrets 2019
May 25th 2019 | David Starr | def. | A-Kid, Adam Foster, Benji, C. J. Banks, Carlos Romo, Conor Renshaw, Drake, Gabriel Kidd, Jack Sexsmith, Joe Hendry, Joe Nelson, John Klinger, Lana Austin, Laura Di Matteo, Lizzy Styles, Los Federales Santos Jr., Man Like DeReiss, Mark Billington, Martin Kirby, Myles Kayman, Nathan Cruz, No Fun Dunne, Prince Ameen, Robbie X., Rory Coyle, Sean Kustom, Simon Miller, Thomas Billington, Visage | Rumble | |
Defiant No Regrets 2019
May 25th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Gabriel Kidd | | |
IWA-MS Mayhem In May
May 16th 2019 | Logan James | def. | David Starr | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 7
May 15th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Josh Briggs | | |
AAW Take No Prisoners 2019
May 11th 2019 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | David Starr | | AAW Heavyweight Title
|
RevPro Epic Encounter 2019
May 10th 2019 | El Phantasmo | def. | David Starr (c) | ladder | RevPro British Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
PROGRESS Chapter 88: Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2019 - Day 3
May 6th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Jordan Devlin | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 88: Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2019 - Day 3
May 6th 2019 | David Starr | def. (pin) | Ilja Dragunov, Travis Banks | three-way elimination | |
PROGRESS Chapter 88: Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2019 - Day 2
May 5th 2019 | David Starr | draw (DCO) | Travis Banks | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 88: Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2019 - Day 1
May 4th 2019 | David Starr | def. (pin) | Artemis Spencer | | |
RevPro Live in Bristol 2
Apr 28th 2019 | David Starr | def. | A-Kid | | |
Defiant Loaded TV Tapings
Apr 27th 2019 | Mark Haskins | def. | David Starr, Nathan Cruz | three-way | |
Defiant Lights Out 2019
Apr 17th 2019 | Gabriel Kidd | def. | David Starr | | |
CZW Best of the Best 18
Apr 13th 2019 | John Silver | def. | David Starr (c) | | CZW Championship
(title change) |
CZW Best of the Best 18
Apr 13th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Anthony Greene (c) | | CZW Championship
(title change) |
CZW Best of the Best 18
Apr 13th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Darius Lockhart, Jimmy Rave, Joey Lynch | four-way | |
AAW EPIC 2019: The 15th Anniversary Show
Apr 12th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Adam Brooks | | |
IWA-MS Thunder Before Thunder
Apr 11th 2019 | Kevin Giza | def. | David Starr | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 2
Apr 10th 2019 | David Starr & MJF | def. | Chris Dickinson & Joey Janela | | |
HOG Culture Clash 19
Apr 6th 2019 | Isiah Kassidy & Marq Quen | def. | David Starr & J. T. Dunn | | |
Wrestling Revolver Pancakes & Piledrivers 3
Apr 6th 2019 | Moose | def. (pin) | Brian Cage, David Starr | three-way | |
Blackcraft No Apologies
Apr 5th 2019 | Johnny Blackcraft (c) | def. (pin) | David Starr | | Blackcraft Heavyweight Title
|
RevPro Live In New York
Apr 5th 2019 | Tomohiro Ishii | def. | David Starr | | |
WrestleCon US Vs. The World
Apr 5th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Daga | | |
wXw Amerika Ist Wunderbar - Live From New York City
Apr 4th 2019 | Lucky Kid | def. | David Starr | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 1
Apr 3rd 2019 | Masato Tanaka | def. | David Starr | | |
RevPro Live at the Cockpit 40
Mar 31st 2019 | David Starr | def. | Michael Oku | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 87: Breadknife
Mar 31st 2019 | David Starr | def. | Connor Mills | | |
wXw 16 Carat Gold Revenge 2019: Frankfurt
Mar 30th 2019 | Veit Müller | def. | David Starr | | |
OTT Live In Belfast: Flipping Assassins
Mar 24th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Flip Gordon | | |
Defiant Loaded TV Tapings
Mar 23rd 2019 | David Starr & Joe Hendry | def. (DQ) | Gabriel Kidd & John Klinger | | |
Defiant Loaded TV Tapings
Mar 23rd 2019 | David Starr | def. | John Klinger | | |
OTT Scrappermania 5
Mar 16th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Dan Barry | | |
David Starr