| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WWE WrestleMania XXVI
Mar 28th 2010 | Yoshi Tatsu | def. | Carlito, Caylen Croft, Chavo Guerrero, Chris Masters, David Hart Smith, Finlay, Goldust, Hornswoggle, Jimmy Wang Yang, JTG, Kung Fu Naki, Luke Gallows, Mark Henry, Mike Knox, Primo, Santino Marella, Shad Gaspard, Slam Master J., The Great Khali, Trent Beretta, Tyler Reks, Tyson Kidd, Vance Archer, Vladimir Kozlov, William Regal, Zack Ryder | pre-show
Battle Royal | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Mar 29th 2010 | Kofi Kingston & Montel Vontavious Porter | def. (pin) | Carlito & Zack Ryder | | |
WWE NXT Season 1 Taping #6
Mar 30th 2010 | CM Punk & Matt Hardy & R-Truth & Wade Barrett | def. (pin) | Carlito & Christian & The Miz & William Regal | 8-person tag | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Apr 5th 2010 | Montel Vontavious Porter | def. (pin) | Carlito | | |
 WWE Monday Night Raw Taping
Apr 12th 2010 | Evan Bourne | def. (pin) | Carlito | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #2
Apr 13th 2010 | Matt Hardy | def. (pin) | Carlito | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
Apr 19th 2010 | John Morrison | def. (pin) | Carlito | | |
WWE Superstars Taping #1
May 3rd 2010 | Carlito | draw (NC) | Primo | | |
 WWC 37th Aniversario 2010 Weekend - Day 2
Jul 10th 2010 | Carlito & Primo Colon | def. | Lightning & Thunder | | |
WWC 37th Aniversario 2010 Weekend - Day 3
Jul 11th 2010 | Booker T. | def. (DQ) | Carlito | | |
WWC 37th Aniversario 2010 Weekend - Day 3
Jul 11th 2010 | Ricky Banderas | def. | Carlito | | |
WWC Bayamon Show (Jul '10)
Jul 31st 2010 | Carlito | def. | Vampiro | | |
LL USA Masked Warriors #7
Aug 5th 2010 | Carlitos & P. R. Flyer & San Juan Kid | def. | El Oriental & Neutronic & Tinieblas Jr. | 6-person tag | |
NEW 15 Year Anniversary Tour
Oct 1st 2010 | Carlito | def. | Robbie E. | | |
NEW Thunderslam
Oct 2nd 2010 | Carlito | def. | Shelton Benjamin | | |
 IGF Inoki Bob-Ba-Ye 2010
Dec 3rd 2010 | Kendo Ka Shin | def. | Carlito | | |
WWC Euphoria 2011 - Day 2
Jan 8th 2011 | Ricky Banderas | def. | Carlito Carribean Cool (c) | referee: Hercules Ayala | WWC Puerto Rico Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
WWC Euphoria 2011 - Day 3
Jan 9th 2011 | MVP & Ricky Banderas | def. | Carlito Carribean Cool & Orlando Colon | | |
VPW Reflexion '11
Mar 12th 2011 | Carlito Colon | def. (pin) | Billy Blade | | |
 AAA Rey de Reyes 2011
Mar 18th 2011 | Extreme Tiger | def. (pin) | Carlito Carribean Cool, El Mesias, L. A. Park | four-way elimination | |
2CW Adrenaline 3
Mar 25th 2011 | Carlito | def. | Jason Axe | | |
JCW Legends & Icons
Aug 12th 2011 | Zach Gowen | def. | Brutus Beefcake, Carlito, Disco Inferno, Doink the Clown (Borne), Headbanger Mosh, Headbanger Thrasher, Jim Duggan, Jimmy Snuka, Rikishi, Rob Conway, Ronnie Garvin, Tony Atlas, U-Gene, Viscera | Battle Royal | |
PWS Fight Night: The 4 Year Anniversary Event
Aug 20th 2011 | Eddie Kingston | def. | Carlito | | |
WWC Euphoria 2012 - Day 1
Jan 6th 2012 | Gilbert | def. | Carlito Carribean Cool | | |
WWC Euphoria 2012 - Day 2
Jan 7th 2012 | Carlito Carribean Cool | draw (time) | Ricky Banderas | | |
2CW Girls Grand Prix 1
Feb 24th 2012 | Carlito | def. | Sean Carr | | |
2CW Drunk With Power
Feb 25th 2012 | Carlito | def. | Zachary Springate III | | |
The Crash III
May 25th 2012 | Hector Garza & Perro Aguayo, Jr. | def. | Carlito & Steve Pain | 2 out of 3 falls Tag Match | |
FWE Dysfunctional Family
Jun 9th 2012 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. | Carlito, Tommy Dreamer | three-way hardcore | FWE Heavyweight Championship
|
WWC 39th Anniversary Show - Day 1
Jun 29th 2012 | Carlito | def. (DQ) | John Morrison | | |
FWE X
Jul 28th 2012 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Brian Kendrick, Carlito, Jay Lethal (c) | fatal 4-way elimination | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
JCW Bloodymania 6
Aug 12th 2012 | Zach Gowen | def. | Bobby Lashley, Carlito, Chris Masters, Rude Boy, Shockwave the Robot, The Weedman, U-Gene, X-Pac | Battle Royal | |
House of Hardcore Debut Show
Oct 6th 2012 | Carlito | def. (pin) | Mike Knoxx (c), Tommy Dreamer (c) | three-way | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
FWE No Limits 2013
Feb 16th 2013 | Carlito (c) | def. | Matt Hardy, Tommy Dreamer | TLC (3-way) | FWE Heavyweight Championship
|
 NWE The Wrestling Show
May 25th 2013 | Carlito | def. | Sam Elias | | |
FWE Welcome to the Rumble 2
Jun 21st 2013 | John Morrison | def. | Carlito (c) | | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
House of Hardcore #2
Jun 22nd 2013 | Carlito | def. (pin) | Mike Bennett | | |
WWC Summer Madness 2013
Jun 29th 2013 | Savio Vega | def. | Carlito Carribean Cool | | |
AAW Scars and Stripes 2013
Jul 27th 2013 | Keith Walker | def. | Carlito | | |
RevPro Summer Sizzler 2013
Aug 18th 2013 | Carlito | def. | Sha Samuels | | |
WWC 40th Anniversary Show
Sep 21st 2013 | Sting | def. | Carlito | | |
FWE Openweight Grand Prix
Oct 12th 2013 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Carlito | | |
House of Hardcore #3
Nov 9th 2013 | Carlito & Rosita | def. (pin) | Stevie Richards & Tara | | |
WWC Crossfire 2013 - Day 1
Nov 16th 2013 | Carlito | def. | Rey Fenix | hair vs. mask | |
WWC Crossfire 2013 - Day 2
Nov 17th 2013 | Carlito | def. | Apolo | | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2013
Nov 30th 2013 | Matt Hardy | def. | Carlito | ladder | Wrestlecade Championship
(title change) |
WWC La Hora De La Verdad 2014 - Day 2
Mar 30th 2014 | Carlito | def. | Invader #1 | | |
DREAMWAVE Retaliation 2014
May 3rd 2014 | Aaron Xavier & Bucky Collins & Mallaki Matthews | def. | Carlito & Dan Lawrence & Judd the Janitor | 6-person tag | |
House of Hardcore VI: West Coast Invasion
Jun 14th 2014 | Matt Hardy | def. (pin) | Carlito, Tommy Dreamer | TLC (3-way) | |
Heroes & Legends IV
Sep 13th 2014 | Dru Skillz (c) | def. | Carlito | | HLW Championship
|
Carlito