| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT TV #600 - Roadblock 2024
Mar 5th 2024 | Shawn Spears | def. (pin) | Uriah Connors | | |
NXT Tampa Show
Feb 16th 2024 | Charlie Dempsey | def. | Brogan Finlay | | |
GCW Si Or No?
Nov 4th 2023 | Tony Deppen | def. | Brogan Finlay | | |
Blitzkrieg! Pro Fall Children '23
Oct 14th 2023 | Dustin Waller (c) & Kylon King (c) | def. | Brogan Finlay | | IWTV Independent Wrestling Tag Team Titles
|
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 24 2023 - Part 2
Sep 23rd 2023 | Cole Radrick (c) | def. | Brogan Finlay | | BLP Heavyweight Title
|
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 24 2023 - Part 1
Sep 23rd 2023 | Brogan Finlay | def. | Sawyer Wreck | | |
GCW Homecoming Weekend 2023 - Day 2
Aug 20th 2023 | Allie Katch & Effy & Sawyer Wreck & The Dark Sheik | def. | Brogan Finlay & Leon Slater & Marcus Mathers & Starboy Charlie | 8-person tag | |
JCW (NJ) Dog Day Afternoon
Aug 20th 2023 | Bam Sullivan & Dyln McKay & Gabriel Skye & Marcus Mathers | def. | Brogan Finlay & Donnie Primetime & Hunter Drake & Rico Gonzalez | 8-person tag | |
Black Label Pro National Slampoon's Wrestling Vacation 2
Jul 22nd 2023 | Brogan Finlay | def. | Crash Jaxon, Tre Lamar, Vinny Pacifico | four-way | |
JCW (NJ) Big Ass Extreme Birthday Bash
Jul 9th 2023 | 1 Called Manders | def. | Bam Sullivan, Brogan Finlay, Charles Mason, Charlie Tiger, Ciclope, CPA, Grim Reefer, Jay Sawyer, John Wayne Murdoch, Kaia McKenna, Marcus Mathers, Miedo Extremo, Parrow, Sleepy Eddy, Steve Off, Steve Scott, YOSHIHIKO, Yoya | "Bunkhouse Stampede" | |
GCW Clean Up Man
Jul 8th 2023 | Alec Price | def. | Brogan Finlay, Dustin Waller, Grim Reefer | four-way | |
Blitzkrieg! Pro The 5th Annual Luau
Jul 7th 2023 | Andy Brown (c) | def. | Brogan Finlay, T. J. Crawford | three-way | Blitzkrieg! Pro Bedlam Title
|
Blitzkrieg! Pro The 5th Annual Luau
Jul 7th 2023 | Brogan Finlay, T. J. Crawford | def. | 50 Cal, Bryce Donovan, CPA, Delightful Dan The God Damn Candy Man, Logan Black, Stephen Azure, Steve Somerset | 9-Way | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 79
Jul 6th 2023 | Gabriel Skye | def. | Brogan Finlay | | |
GCW Backyard Wrestling 5
Jul 4th 2023 | Pizza Cat Jr. | def. | Charlie Cactus | | |
GCW/New South GCW Vs. New South 2
Jun 25th 2023 | Jack Cartwheel | def. | Brogan Finlay | | |
GCW Mastermind
Jun 24th 2023 | Brandon Williams & Brayden Toon & Cabana Man Dan & Donnie Primetime | def. | 1 Called Manders & Brogan Finlay & Jack Cartwheel & Starboy Charlie | 8-person tag | |
Wrestling Revolver And The Ring of Destiny
Jun 17th 2023 | Allie Katch & Logan James | def. | Billie Starkz & Brogan Finlay | | |
Black Label Pro Fancy Wrestling 2
Jun 3rd 2023 | Brogan Finlay | def. | Hunter Drake, Rico Gonzalez | three-way | |
Black Label Pro 2 Cold 2 Hold
Apr 29th 2023 | Brogan Finlay | def. | Matt Brannigan | | |
GCW Scene Of The Crime
Apr 22nd 2023 | Allie Katch & Effy & The Dark Sheik | def. | Billie Starkz & Brogan Finlay & Cole Radrick | 6-person tag | |
GCW Into The Light
Apr 21st 2023 | Adam Priest | def. | Brogan Finlay | | |
GCW Jimmy Lloyd's D-Generation F 2023
Mar 31st 2023 | Terry Yaki | def. | Bobby Flaco, Brogan Finlay, Lucas Riley, Man Like DeReiss, MBM, Midas Kreed | 7-way | |
Black Label Pro All My Friends Are Enemies
Feb 18th 2023 | Billie Starkz (c) | def. | Brogan Finlay | street fight | BLP Heavyweight Title
|
GCW Take A Picture 2023
Jan 21st 2023 | Hunter Drake | def. | Brandon Williams, Brogan Finlay, Donnie Primetime, Jimmy Lloyd, Marcus Mathers, Terry Yaki, Yoya | 8-way | |
Brogan Finlay