| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WWE Smackdown! Taping
Dec 29th 2009 | Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Dec 20th 2009 | Maria Kanellis & Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix & Layla | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Dec 15th 2009 | Beth Phoenix | def. | Maria Kanellis | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Dec 14th 2009 | Brie Bella & Gail Kim & Kelly Kelly & Maria Kanellis & Melina & Mickie James & Nikki Bella | def. (pin) | Alicia Fox & Beth Phoenix & Layla & Maryse & Michelle McCool & Natalya & Rosa Mendes | 14 diva tag | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Nov 29th 2009 | Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix, Natalya | three-way | |
WWE Survivor Series '09
Nov 22nd 2009 | Eve Torres & Gail Kim & Kelly Kelly & Melina & Mickie James | def. (pin) | Alicia Fox & Beth Phoenix & Jillian Hall & Layla & Michelle McCool | "Survivor Series" | |
 WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 15th 2009 | Katie Lea Burchill & Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix & Michelle McCool | | |
 WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 14th 2009 | Katie Lea Burchill & Mickie James | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix & Michelle McCool | | |
 WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 13th 2009 | Katie Lea Burchill & Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix & Michelle McCool | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 12th 2009 | Katie Lea Burchill & Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix & Michelle McCool | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 11th 2009 | Katie Lea Burchill & Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix & Michelle McCool | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Nov 10th 2009 | Beth Phoenix | def. | Lisa Taylor | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 9th 2009 | Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix, Katie Lea Burchill, Layla, Natalya, Rosa Mendes | Battle Royal | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 8th 2009 | Michelle McCool (c) | def. | Beth Phoenix | | WWE Women's Championship (original)
|
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 8th 2009 | Beth Phoenix | def. | Katie Lea Burchill, Layla, Mickie James, Natalya, Rosa Mendes | Battle Royal | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 7th 2009 | Natalya | def. | Beth Phoenix, Katie Lea Burchill, Layla, Mickie James, Rosa Mendes | Battle Royal | |
 WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 6th 2009 | Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix, Katie Lea Burchill, Layla, Natalya, Rosa Mendes | Battle Royal | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown & ECW)
Nov 5th 2009 | Mickie James | def. | Beth Phoenix, Katie Lea Burchill, Layla, Natalya, Rosa Mendes | Battle Royal | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Nov 3rd 2009 | Beth Phoenix | def. | Brittney Carter | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Oct 27th 2009 | Beth Phoenix | def. (pin) | Jenny Brooks | | |
WWE Bragging Rights '09
Oct 25th 2009 | Beth Phoenix & Michelle McCool & Natalya | def. (pin) | Gail Kim & Kelly Kelly & Melina | 6-person tag | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Oct 12th 2009 | Gail Kim & Kelly Kelly & Maria Menounos | def. (pin) | Alicia Fox & Beth Phoenix & Rosa Mendes | 6-person tag | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Oct 5th 2009 | Brie Bella & Eve Torres & Kelly Kelly & Maria Kanellis & Melina & Mickie James & Nikki Bella | def. (pin) | Alicia Fox & Beth Phoenix & Jillian Hall & Layla & Michelle McCool & Natalya & Rosa Mendes | 14 diva tag | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Sep 21st 2009 | Beth Phoenix | def. (pin) | Mickie James | | |
 WWE Monday Night Raw
Sep 14th 2009 | Mark Henry & Montel Vontavious Porter & Trish Stratus | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix & Chris Jericho & The Big Show | 6-person tag | |
Beth Phoenix during 2009