| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 TNA Xplosion #83 Taping
Jun 9th 2004 | Abyss & Monty Brown | def. (pin) | Bart Sawyer & Shane Matthews | | |
 NWA 56th Anniversary Show: Night 1
Oct 15th 2004 | Shane Matthews | def. | Keith Loughman | | |
NWA 56th Anniversary Show: Night 2
Oct 17th 2004 | Will Phoenix | def. | Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Tag World Grand Prix '06 - Day 2
Feb 25th 2006 | Mister Zero & Shane Storm | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Tag World Grand Prix '06 - Day 3
Feb 26th 2006 | Dragon Dragon & Necro Butcher & Player Uno & Retail Dragon & Sexxxy Eddy | def. | Jagged & Larry Sweeney & Phil Davis & Sean Davis & Shane Matthews | 10-person tag | |
CHIKARA Sand in the Vaseline
Apr 21st 2006 | Eddie Kingston & Sabian | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Delta
May 26th 2006 | Miyawaki & Yoshiaki Yago | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | Gauntlet (tag) | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '07: Night 1
Feb 16th 2007 | Jigsaw & Shane Storm | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '07: Night 2
Feb 17th 2007 | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush & Shane Storm | def. | Jagged & Maxime Boyer & Shane Matthews | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '07: Night 3
Feb 18th 2007 | Cheech & Cloudy | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews, American Balloon & Danshoku Dino, Chris Bosh & Scott Lost, Jason Gory & Shiima Xion, Create-A-Wrestler & Player Uno, Equinox & Fire Ant, Excalibur & Joey Ryan, Larry Sweeney & Sharecropper, Mitch Ryder & Robbie Ellis, Soldier Ant & Worker Ant, Brandon Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli, J. C. Ryder & Lucky, Colin Olsen & Jimmy Olsen, Hydra & Ultramantis Black, Darkness Crabtree & Dr. Cheung, Dunn & Marcos | tag team gauntlet | |
CHIKARA Best Imitation of Myself
Mar 23rd 2007 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Joker & Sabian | | |
IWA-MS Candido Cup 2007 - Night 1
May 25th 2007 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Darin Corbin & Ryan Cruz | | |
IWA-MS Candido Cup 2007 - Night 2
May 26th 2007 | Cheech & Cloudy | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Showdown in CrisisLand
Jul 21st 2007 | Jagged & Shane Matthews & Shayne Hawke | def. | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush & Shane Storm | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Maximum Overdraft
Aug 5th 2007 | El Hijo del Ice Cream & Ice Cream Jr. | draw | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CZW Lights! Camera! CZW! Fuck Hollywood!
Mar 8th 2008 | Beef Wellington & Greg Excellent | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews, Cheech & Cloudy | three-way tag | |
PWG Dynamite Duumvirate Tag Team Title Tournament '08 - Day 1
May 17th 2008 | Phoenix Star & Zokre | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
PWG Dynamite Duumvirate Tag Team Title Tournament '08 - Day 2
May 18th 2008 | Hook Bomberry & Joey Ryan & Scott Lost & T. J. Perkins | def. | Candice LeRae & Jagged & Scorpio Sky & Shane Matthews | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA AnniversarioMA
May 23rd 2008 | Amasis & Ophidian | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CZW Summer School
Jun 14th 2008 | Beef Wellington & Greg Excellent | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews, Bruce Maxwell & T. J. Cannon | three-way dance tag | |
CZW Deja Vu IV
Aug 9th 2008 | Alex Colon & Joe Gacy | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
 wXw/CHIKARA Tag World Grand Prix '08 - Day 1
Nov 8th 2008 | Andrew Patterson & Tommy End | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
wXw/CHIKARA Tag World Grand Prix '08 - Day 2
Nov 9th 2008 | Kid Fite & Lionheart & Sha Samuels | def. | Jagged & Karsten Beck & Shane Matthews | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Cibernetico Begins
Nov 15th 2008 | Player Dos & Player Uno | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Armdrags to Riches
Nov 16th 2008 | Cheech & Cloudy & Player Dos & Player Uno | def. | El Hijo del Ice Cream & Ice Cream Jr. & Jagged & Shane Matthews | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA Face with a View
Dec 12th 2008 | Cheech & Cloudy | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Duel and Duality
Dec 14th 2008 | Fire Ant & Soldier Ant | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CZW A Decade of Destruction - 10th Anniversary Show
Feb 14th 2009 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Joel Maximo & Jose Maximo | Gauntlet (tag) | |
CZW A Decade of Destruction - 10th Anniversary Show
Feb 14th 2009 | Adam Cole & Tyler Veritas | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | Gauntlet (tag) | |
Capital City Championship Combat Domination
Mar 7th 2009 | Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. (pin) | Black Serpent & Jae Rennals | | |
CHIKARA Behind the 8 Ball
Apr 25th 2009 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked | | |
CHIKARA The Bobliographon
Apr 26th 2009 | Cheech & Cloudy | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews, Player Dos & Player Uno, Colin Delaney & STIGMA | four-way elimination tag | |
Capital City Championship Combat Stand Alone
May 2nd 2009 | Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. | Josh Alexander & Mike Rollins | | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Yin
May 23rd 2009 | Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Yang
May 24th 2009 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Hydra & Tim Donst | | |
 CHIKARA/BJW The Global Gauntlet II - Day 1
Jun 12th 2009 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Atsushi Ohashi & Mototsugu Shimizu | | |
CHIKARA/BJW The Global Gauntlet II - Day 2
Jun 13th 2009 | Ryuichi Kawakami & Yoshihito Sasaki | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA/BJW The Global Gauntlet II - Day 2
Jun 13th 2009 | Atsushi Ohashi & Fire Ant & Green Ant (Miyakami) & Jaki Numazawa & Soldier Ant | def. | Chuck Taylor & Crossbones & Jagged & Shane Matthews & Ultramantis Black | 10-person tag | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '09 - Day 1
Aug 14th 2009 | Fire Ant & Soldier Ant | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA Man Makes Plans and God Laughs
Sep 12th 2009 | Brad Badd & Chad Badd | def. | Fire Ant & Green Ant | | |
CHIKARA Hiding in Plain Sight
Sep 13th 2009 | Carpenter Ant & Colt Cabana & Dasher Hatfield & Green Ant & Lince Dorado | def. | Colin Delaney & Jagged & Shane Matthews & STIGMA & Vin Gerard | 10-person tag | |
CHIKARA Throwing Life's Instructions Away
Nov 21st 2009 | Brad Badd & Chad Badd | def. | Helios & Lince Dorado | | |
CHIKARA The Mint Condition
Feb 27th 2010 | Amasis & Frightmare & Hallowicked & Ophidian | def. (pin) | Brad Badd & Chad Badd & Gran Akuma & Icarus | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA A World of Comforting Illusions
Feb 28th 2010 | Ares & Claudio Castagnoli | def. (pin) | Amasis & Ophidian, Brad Badd & Chad Badd, Player Dos & Player Uno | four-way elimination tag | |
CHIKARA Dead Men Don't Laugh (Testimony of Evil)
Mar 21st 2010 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Crossbones & Ultramantis Black | | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Elf
May 23rd 2010 | Equinox II & Helios | def. | Chuck Taylor & Gran Akuma, Player Dos & Player Uno, Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | four-way elimination tag | |
CHIKARA We Must Eat Michigan's Brain
Jun 26th 2010 | Equinox II & Helios & Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & STIGMA & Vin Gerard | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA Faded Scars and Lines
Jun 27th 2010 | Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '10 - Day 2
Aug 28th 2010 | Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. (pin) | Player Dos & Player Uno | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '10 - Day 3
Aug 29th 2010 | Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. (pin) | Christin Able & Josh Raymond | | |
Matt Menard