| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WWF WWF Live
Feb 2nd 1996 | Bart Gunn & Henry O. Godwinn | def. | Tatanka & The 1-2-3 Kid | | |
 WWF WWF Live
Jan 27th 1996 | The Ringmaster | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF MSG Show (Jan '96)
Jan 26th 1996 | Steve Austin | def. (sub) | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #489
Jan 23rd 1996 | Henry O. Godwinn & Phineas I. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Joe Gomez & The Brooklyn Brawler | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #487
Jan 23rd 1996 | Henry O. Godwinn & Phineas I. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Ed Moretti & James Samudo | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw Taping
Jan 22nd 1996 | Henry O. Godwinn & Phineas I. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Skip & Zip | | |
WWF Royal Rumble '96
Jan 21st 1996 | Shawn Michaels | def. | Aldo Montoya, Barry Horowitz, Bob Backlund, Bob Holly, Diesel, Dory Funk, Jr., Doug Gilbert, Duke Droese, Fatu, Hakushi, Henry O. Godwinn, Hunter Hearst Helmsley, Isaac Yankem, DDS, Jake Roberts, Jerry Lawler, Kama, King Mabel, Marty Jannetty, Owen Hart, Savio Vega, Squat Team #1, Squat Team #2, Takao Omori, Tatanka, The 1-2-3 Kid, The British Bulldog, The Ringmaster, Vader, Yokozuna | 30-man Royal Rumble | |
 WWF WWF Live
Jan 12th 1996 | Goldust | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF WWF Live
Dec 30th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | The Brooklyn Brawler | | |
WWF WWF Live
Dec 29th 1995 | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | slopbucket | |
WWF WWF Live
Dec 26th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. | The Brooklyn Brawler | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #484
Dec 19th 1995 | Owen Hart | def. (pin) | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #482
Dec 19th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | The Brooklyn Brawler | | |
WWF In Your House 5: Season's Beatings
Dec 17th 1995 | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | referee: Hillbilly Jim
Arkansas Hog Pen | |
WWF WWF Live
Dec 4th 1995 | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF WWF Live
Nov 29th 1995 | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF MSG Show (Nov '95)
Nov 25th 1995 | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | def. (pin) | Henry O. Godwinn | slopbucket | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #478
Nov 20th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Jason Arhndt | | |
WWF Survivor Series '95
Nov 19th 1995 | Fatu & Henry O. Godwinn & Savio Vega & The Undertaker | def. (CO) | Hunter Hearst Helmsley & Isaac Yankem, DDS & Jerry Lawler & King Mabel | "Survivor Series" | |
WWF WWF Live
Nov 10th 1995 | Isaac Yankem, DDS | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF WWF Live
Nov 6th 1995 | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #475
Oct 24th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Otis Apollo | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw Taping
Oct 23rd 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Terry Richards | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw
Oct 23rd 1995 | Owen Hart | def. (pin) | Aldo Montoya, Bam Bam Bigelow, Barry Horowitz, Bob Holly, Duke Droese, Fatu, Hakushi, Henry O. Godwinn, Hunter Hearst Helmsley, Isaac Yankem, DDS, Jean-Pierre Lafitte, Kama, King Kong Bundy, Marty Jannetty, Rad Radford, Savio Vega, Skip, Sycho Sid, The 1-2-3 Kid | Battle Royal | |
WWF Monday Night Raw Taping
Oct 23rd 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | draw (NC) | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | | |
WWF In Your House 4: Great White North
Oct 22nd 1995 | Sycho Sid | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | dark
| |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #471
Sep 26th 1995 | Kama & Sycho Sid | def. (pin) | Bam Bam Bigelow & Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF In Your House 3: Triple Header
Sep 24th 1995 | Sycho Sid | def. (pin) | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF WWF Live
Sep 9th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (CO) | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | | |
WWF WWF Live
Sep 8th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (CO) | Hunter Hearst Helmsley | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #468
Aug 29th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | King Kong Bundy | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #469
Aug 29th 1995 | Kama & Tatanka | def. (CO) | Bam Bam Bigelow & Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #465
Aug 15th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. | The Brooklyn Brawler | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #466
Aug 15th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | A. C. Conner | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #466
Aug 15th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Mike Bell | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw
Aug 14th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Russ Greenberg | | |
WWF MSG Show (Aug '95)
Aug 12th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Adam Bomb | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #464
Jul 26th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. | Brickhouse Brown | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #462
Jul 25th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. | Jerry Flynn | | |
WWF In Your House 2: The Lumberjacks
Jul 23rd 1995 | Bam Bam Bigelow | def. (pin) | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #462
Jun 28th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Jerry Flynn | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #457
Jun 27th 1995 | Adam Bomb | draw (DCO) | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw Taping
Jun 26th 1995 | Lex Luger & The British Bulldog | def. (pin) | Henry O. Godwinn & Tatanka | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw Taping
Jun 26th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Barry Horowitz | | |
WWF Action Zone #34
Jun 7th 1995 | Bret Hart | def. | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #455
Jun 6th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (CO) | Bret Hart | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #454
May 17th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | John Crystal | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #452
Apr 26th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. (pin) | Gary Scott | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #450
Apr 25th 1995 | Diesel | def. (pin) | Henry O. Godwinn | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #447
Apr 5th 1995 | Henry O. Godwinn | def. | Steve King | | |
Henry O. Godwinn