| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AIW Gauntlet for the Gold
Dec 11th 2005 | Michael Hutter | def. | Carlton Kaz, Chris Cronus, Christian Faith, Dan Cull, Dick Wiggler, Dios Salvador, Eastside Eddie, Jason Thunder, John Thorne, Johnny Beef, Johnny Gargano, Kano, King Cob, Malcolm Farrakhan, Marion Fontaine, Mike Stryker, Morty Rackem, Rufio Rapier, Super Oprah, Syd Smythe, The Butcher, The Masked Fish, The Moonshine Bunny, The Savage, The Unknown, Thomas Von Erich, Tony Galloway, Vincent Nothing, Virus | Battle Royal | |
AIW Night of Mystery
Feb 26th 2006 | Kano | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW This Is Now
Mar 26th 2006 | Starless | def. | Dios Salvador, Johnny Gargano, Patrick Hayes, Shawn Blaze, Shiima Xion | 6-Way | AIW Intense Championship
(title change) |
AIW Set It Off
Apr 30th 2006 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Tyrone Evans | | |
AIW Absolution
May 28th 2006 | Dios Salvador (c) | def. | Johnny Gargano, Starless | three-way | AIW Intense Championship
|
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Mar 20th 2007 | Montel Vontavious Porter | def. | Cedrick Von Haussen | | |
IWC Super Indy VI
May 11th 2007 | Johnny Gargano & Michael Facade | def. | Antonio Thomas & Romeo Roselli & Eric Xtasy & Justin Idol & Jimmy DeMarco & Vendetta & J-Rocc & Raymond Rowe & Marshall Gambino (c) & Mickey Gambino (c) | Gauntlet (tag) | IWC Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
AIW Nightmare Before X-Mas
Dec 16th 2007 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Shane Hollister | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 3
Feb 24th 2008 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Josh Prohibition | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 3
Feb 24th 2008 | Sterling James Keenan | def. | Benny Boone, Chris Cronus, Dios Salvador, Dubleve, Eric Ryan, Gregory Iron, Hailey Hatred, Hobo Joe, Jim Roberts, Joey the Snake, John Thorne, Johnny Gargano, Josh Prohibition, K-Fed, Luis Diamante, Mad Man Pondo, Marion Fontaine, Matt Cross, Matt Riot, Matthew Justice, Mike Tolar, Nick Belushi, Rebis, Southside St. Clair, T. J. Dynamite, The Potato, The Savage (Rebis), Thomas Von Erich, Vincent Nothing | Battle Royal | AIW Absolute Championship
|
AIW Destroy Everything!
Mar 21st 2008 | Tyler Black (c) | draw (time) | Johnny Gargano | | AIW Intense Championship
|
AIW Absolution 3: Guerrilla Warfare
May 25th 2008 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Tyler Black (c) | Iron Man | AIW Intense Championship
(title change) |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '08 - Day 2
Jun 14th 2008 | Marshe Rockett | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
ROH Age Of Insanity
Aug 15th 2008 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Sami Callihan | dark
| |
AIW Die Another Day
Sep 21st 2008 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Shiima Xion | | AIW Intense Championship
|
CHIKARA Laying in the Gutter, Looking at the Stars
Sep 21st 2008 | Jimmy Olsen | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 4
Feb 28th 2009 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Jimmy DeMarco (c) | | AIW Intense Championship
(title change) |
AIW Good Times, Great Memories
Apr 11th 2009 | Facade & Shiima Xion | def. | Jason Gory & Johnny Gargano | | |
AAW Point of No Return 2009
May 1st 2009 | Shane Hollister | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW Girls' Night Out
May 15th 2009 | Josh Prohibition | def. | Johnny Gargano (c) | | AIW Intense Championship
(title change) |
AIW Zero Hour
May 21st 2009 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Louis Lyndon | | |
AIW Absolution 4
Jun 12th 2009 | Josh Prohibition (c) | def. | Facade, Johnny Gargano | three-way | AIW Intense Championship
|
Dragon Gate USA Open The Historic Gate
Jul 25th 2009 | Lince Dorado | def. | Aaron Arbo, Andy Harner, Cheech, Chris Jones, Cloudy, Johnny Gargano, Louis Lyndon | dark
8-way elimination | |
AIW Honor and Vengeance
Aug 28th 2009 | Facade | def. | Johnny Gargano, Sonjay Dutt | three-way | AIW Intense Championship
(title change) |
AAW Us vs. Them
Sep 5th 2009 | Shiima Xion | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
Johnny Gargano