| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 EVOLVE/NYWC Rocks Off's Cinco De Mayo Festival
Mar 5th 2012 | Shane Strickland & The Latin Dragon | def. | Nate Carter & The DMC | | |
CZW TV Tapings
Apr 27th 2012 | Joe Gacy & Ryan Slater | def. | Nate Wallace & The DMC | | |
CZW Cerebral '12
Oct 13th 2012 | Mr. Nate Carter & The DMC | def. | Biff Busick & Drolix | dark
| |
Beyond Charade Charity Chowdown
Nov 4th 2012 | Ray-Ray Marz | def. | Dave McCall | | |
CZW Ascension
Jan 12th 2013 | Nate Wallace & The DMC | def. | David Starr & The Latin Dragon | | |
CZW Dojo Wars
May 21st 2014 | Brittany Blake & David McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Alexander James & Brooke Danielle & D. J. Hyde | 6-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars II
Jun 4th 2014 | David McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Alexander James & Baja Benjamin | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 3
Jun 18th 2014 | Sozio | def. | David McCall | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 4
Jul 2nd 2014 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Jamel Harris & John E. Rock | | |
CZW Dojo Wars V
Jul 16th 2014 | Dave McCall | def. | Brittany Blake, Kit Osbourne | three-way | |
CZW Dojo Wars 6
Jul 30th 2014 | Eric Corvis & Sozio & Trooper Audubon | def. (pin) | Brittany Blake & Dave McCall & Nate Carter | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CZW Dojo Wars 7
Aug 13th 2014 | Dave McCall | def. (pin) | Chuck Mambo | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 8
Aug 27th 2014 | Andrew Wolf & Chuck Mambo | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 10
Sep 24th 2014 | Dave McCall | def. | Joey Janela | 2 out of 3 falls | |
CZW Maven Bentley Association Show: The Memory Remains 2
Oct 11th 2014 | David McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Conor Claxton & Frankie Pickard | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 12 - Tournament of Valor Quarter Finals
Oct 22nd 2014 | Nate Carter | def. (pin) | Dave McCall | 2 out of 3 falls | |
CZW Dojo Wars 13 - Tournament of Valor Semifinals
Nov 5th 2014 | Dave McCall & Dorian Graves & Frankie Pickard & Kit Osbourne & Kyle the Beast | def. (pin) | Eric Corvis & Jonathan Evans & Observant Othello & Preacher Finneus James & Trooper Audubon | 10-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 15
Dec 3rd 2014 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. (pin) | Eric Corvis & Myke Quest | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 17
Dec 31st 2014 | Penelope Ford | def. | Dave McCall | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 18
Jan 14th 2015 | Dave McCall & Frankie Pickard & Nate Carter | def. | Lennon Duffy & Marcus Clutch & Slugger Clark | 6-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 21
Feb 25th 2015 | Rex Lawless & Ryan Galeone & Trooper Audubon | def. (pin) | Aria Cadenza & Dave McCall & Nate Carter | 6-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 29
May 27th 2015 | Curt Robinson & George Gatton | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 31
Jun 10th 2015 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. (pin) | Dan O'Hare & George Gatton | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 32
Jun 17th 2015 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. (pin) | Hakim Ali & Nick Payne | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 34
Jul 1st 2015 | George Gatton & Rex Lawless | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 35
Jul 8th 2015 | Dave McCall | def. | George Gatton | | |
CZW Retribution 2015
Aug 8th 2015 | Chigusa Nagayo & Takaaki Watanabe | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 40: The Last Blitz of Zandig
Aug 12th 2015 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Kyle the Beast & Steve Mack | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 42
Aug 26th 2015 | Dan O'Hare & Eddy Blackwater & Josh Adams | def. | Dave McCall & Joe Gacy & Nate Carter | 6-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 43
Sep 2nd 2015 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Frankie Pickard & George Gatton | | |
CZW Down With The Sickness 2015
Sep 12th 2015 | Dave Crist & Jake Crist | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 45
Sep 16th 2015 | David McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Hous Blazer & Pete Lightning | | |
CZW Tangled Web 8
Oct 10th 2015 | Pectoral Poseidon & Sea Friend #1 & Sea Friend #2 | def. | Dave McCall & Frankie Pickard & Nate Carter | dark
6-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 49: The Amazing, The Bad, and The Scary
Oct 14th 2015 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. (pin) | Cyrus Deville & Ian Aldwin | | |
CZW Maven Bentley Association Show: The Memory Remains 3
Oct 25th 2015 | Curt Robinson & Neiko Sozio | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Cerebral
Nov 7th 2015 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Desmond Xavier & Matt Taylor | dark
| |
Beyond Tournament for Tomorrow 4 - Day 1
Nov 28th 2015 | Chris Dickinson & Jaka | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter, Logan Black & Rude Boy Riley, Drew Gulak & Rory Gulak | four-way tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars Mega Event
Dec 12th 2015 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter & Penelope Ford | def. | America Monroe & Gully Washer Greg & Mike McCallister | 6-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 55
Dec 30th 2015 | Curt Robinson | def. | Dave McCall | | |
 Smash (Canada)/CZW Smash vs. CZW
Jan 16th 2016 | John Greed & Sebastian Suave | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 61
Feb 10th 2016 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Joe Keys & Robert Locke | | |
CZW Seventeen
Feb 13th 2016 | Drew Gulak & Rory Gulak | def. (pin) | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 63
Feb 24th 2016 | Dave McCall & Hous Blazer & Nate Carter & Pete Lightning | def. (pin) | Joe Keys & Kit Osbourne & Max Caster & Robert Locke | 8-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars Mega Event #2
Mar 25th 2016 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. | Isaac Atrox & Lloyd Jameson | | |
CZW Proving Grounds 2016
Mar 26th 2016 | BLK Jeez & Pepper Parks | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
Hybrid Live Pro Wrestling
Apr 16th 2016 | Joey Janela | def. | Aaron Bradley, Archadia, Conor Claxton, Dave McCall, Nate Carter | 6-way elimination | |
CZW Dojo Wars 73
May 4th 2016 | Joe Keys & Robert Locke | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 90
Aug 31st 2016 | Dave McCall & Nate Carter | def. (pin) | Eddy McQueen & Rick Cataldo | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 96
Oct 12th 2016 | Blackwater | def. | Dave McCall | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 100
Nov 9th 2016 | Billy Danvers & Jimmy Lloyd | def. | Dave McCall & Nate Carter, Ace Austin & Laszlo Arpad, Mike Del & Tahir James | four-way tag | |
Dave McCall