| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Smash (Canada) Any Given Sunday 4
Mar 20th 2016 | TARIK | def. | Andy Williams | | |
 AIW At Vans Warped Tour 2016
Jul 20th 2016 | Andy Williams & Facade | def. | Alex Daniels & Gregory Iron | | |
Smash (Canada) This is Smash 4th Anniversary Tour - Day 3
Nov 13th 2016 | Andy Williams & Franky the Mobster | def. | Mike Rollins & Pepper Parks | | |
GCW Joey Janela's Spring Break!
Mar 30th 2017 | Andy Williams & Penelope Ford | def. (pin) | Allie & Braxton Sutter | | |
Smash (Canada) New GIrl In Town
Apr 9th 2017 | Kevin Bennett | def. | Andy Williams | | |
AIW WrestleRager 2
Aug 26th 2017 | Andy Williams & Dominic Garrini | def. | Brian Carson & Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham | | |
Smash (Canada) No Change My Heart Shall Fear
Dec 17th 2017 | Kevin Blackwood & Scotty O'Shea | def. | Andy Williams & Brody King | | |
Smash (Canada) Attack the Kingdom
Jan 19th 2018 | Andy Williams & Braxton Sutter | def. | Idris Abraham & Joe Coleman | | |
Bar Wrestling 11: April O'Neil
Apr 12th 2018 | Eli Drake & Joey Ryan & Kevin Martenson | def. | Andy Williams & Braxton Sutter & Brody King | 6-person tag | |
Smash (Canada) It's All Fun And Games (Until Someone Gets Hurt)
Apr 15th 2018 | Andy Williams & Puf | def. | Anthony Gaines & Kevin Blanchard | | |
Blackcraft Burning Bridges
Aug 24th 2018 | Dave Crist & Jake Crist | def. | Andy Williams & Braxton Sutter, Duke Davis & Ganon Jones Jr., Josh Prohibition & Matt Cross | four-way tag | Blackcraft Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
Blackcraft Spirits of the Dead
Dec 15th 2018 | Andy Williams & Braxton Sutter | def. (DQ) | Dave Crist (c) & Jake Crist (c) | | Blackcraft Tag Team Titles
|
Smash (Canada) In Your Dreams
Dec 16th 2018 | Anthony Gaines & Scotty O'Shea & Shane Sabre | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks & Tyler Bateman | 6-person tag | |
Bar Wrestling 30: Three's Company - Day 1
Feb 20th 2019 | Christopher Daniels & Frankie Kazarian & Scorpio Sky | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks & Tyler Bateman | 6-person tag | |
Bar Wrestling 31: Three's Company - Day 2
Feb 21st 2019 | Gregory Iron & Zach Gowen | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks, Eli Drake & Ryan Taylor, Jungle Boy & Luchasaurus | four-way tag | |
GCW/SFP Suburban Fight vs. GCW II
Mar 3rd 2019 | Nick Gage | def. | Andy Williams | | |
Limitless Welcome To The Dance
Mar 9th 2019 | Jay Freddie & Puf | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Smash (Canada) Tell All Your Friends
Mar 24th 2019 | Andy Williams & Mike Rollins & Pepper Parks | def. | Idris Abraham & Joe Coleman & Kevin Bennett | 6-person tag | |
Smash (Canada) Louder Now!
Mar 31st 2019 | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | def. (pin) | Mike Rollins & Mike Rollins' Conscience | | |
GCW Josh Barnett's Bloodsport
Apr 4th 2019 | Chris Dickinson | def. (sub) | Andy Williams | | |
Blackcraft No Apologies
Apr 5th 2019 | Duke Davis & Ganon Jones Jr. | def. (pin) | Dave Crist (c) & Jake Crist (c) & Alexander James & Jurn Simmons & Andy Williams & Pepper Parks & Bestia 666 & Damian 666 | 5-Way Tag | Blackcraft Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
Black Label Pro Player's Brawl
Apr 20th 2019 | Dominic Garrini & Kevin Ku | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 4
Apr 24th 2019 | Alex Reynolds & John Silver | def. (pin) | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Smash (Canada) Just a Little Dramatic
Apr 27th 2019 | Brent Banks & Tyson Dux | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 7
May 15th 2019 | Bear Beefcake & Bear Bronson | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Beyond Secret Show
Jun 9th 2019 | Chris Dickinson & Joey Janela | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 16
Jul 17th 2019 | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | def. | Jay Freddie & Rory Gulak | | |
LVAC Let's Hang Out! '19
Jul 19th 2019 | Andy Williams & Faye Jackson & Orange Cassidy & Pepper Parks | def. | Allie Kat & Chuck Taylor & Hallowicked & Merlok | 8-person tag | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 17
Jul 24th 2019 | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | def. | Anthony Greene & Josh Briggs | | |
Beyond Americanrana 2019
Jul 28th 2019 | Ricky Morton & Robert Gibson | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 18
Jul 31st 2019 | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | def. | Brandon Watts & Randy Summers | | |
PROGRESS Toronto
Aug 8th 2019 | Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks, Evil Uno & Stu Grayson | three-way tag | |
AIW WrestleRager 4
Aug 24th 2019 | Marino Tenaglia (c) & Philly Collins (c) | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | AIW Tag Team Championship
|
Limitless Know Your Enemy
Sep 6th 2019 | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | def. | Chris Dickinson & Tom Lawlor | | |
Beyond Sodom And Gomorrah
Oct 12th 2019 | Bill Carr & Dan Barry | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Season 2 Episode 3
Oct 17th 2019 | Chris Dickinson & Pinkie Sanchez | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Season 2 Episode 4
Oct 24th 2019 | Bill Carr & Dan Barry | def. | Andy Williams & Pepper Parks, Bear Beefcake & Bear Bronson, Dominic Garrini & Kevin Ku | four-way tag | |
Limitless Fresh Blood
Oct 25th 2019 | Christian Casanova & J. T. Dunn & Joshua Bishop | def. | Andy Williams & Kevin Blackwood & Pepper Parks | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #11
Dec 11th 2019 | The Blade & The Butcher | def. (pin) | Cody & Q. T. Marshall | | |
AEW Dynamite #12
Dec 18th 2019 | Cody & Darby Allin | def. (pin) | The Blade & The Butcher | | |
AEW Dynamite #15 - Bash At The Beach
Jan 15th 2020 | MJF & The Blade & The Butcher | def. (pin) | Diamond Dallas Page & Dustin Rhodes & Q. T. Marshall | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #17
Jan 29th 2020 | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. (pin) | The Blade & The Butcher | | |
AEW Dynamite #18
Feb 5th 2020 | Adam Page & Kenny Omega & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. (pin) | Pentagon Jr. & Rey Fenix & The Blade & The Butcher | 8-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #20
Feb 19th 2020 | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. | Alex Reynolds & John Silver, Angélico & Jack Evans, The Blade & The Butcher, Chuck Taylor & Trent, CIMA & T-Hawk, Frankie Kazarian & Scorpio Sky, Isiah Kassidy & Marq Quen, Jungle Boy & Luchasaurus, Ortiz & Santana | tag team battle royale | |
AEW Dynamite #21
Feb 26th 2020 | Chuck Taylor & Trent | def. (pin) | The Blade & The Butcher | | |
AEW Dynamite #23
Mar 11th 2020 | MJF & The Blade & The Butcher | def. (sub) | Jungle Boy & Luchasaurus & Marko Stunt | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #24
Mar 18th 2020 | Jungle Boy & Luchasaurus | def. (pin) | The Blade & The Butcher | | |
AEW Dark #36 Taping
May 27th 2020 | The Blade & The Butcher | def. (pin) | Joe Alonzo & Jon Cruz | | |
AEW Dark #37 Taping
May 28th 2020 | The Blade & The Butcher | def. (pin) | Anthony Catena & Pineapple Pete | | |
AEW Dynamite #36
Jun 10th 2020 | Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood | def. (pin) | The Blade & The Butcher | | |
The Butcher